Home News & Insights No Revenue, All Risk: Why Decommissioning Disputes are Inevitable
Decommissioning is often treated as the final chapter of an upstream project. In reality, it is one of the most legally and commercially complex phases of the asset lifecycle. As basins mature and cessation of production accelerates, the scale, cost and risk profile of decommissioning are becoming central to industry strategy rather than an afterthought.
The legal challenges facing the hydrocarbons industry in decommissioning infrastructure arise from the interaction between multiple regimes: international conventions (including UNCLOS and regional instruments such as OSPAR), national decommissioning frameworks and highly fragmented contractual arrangements spanning operators, joint venture partners and an extensive supply chain. These overlapping layers frequently operate at different levels of maturity and are often not fully aligned, creating fertile ground for disputes.
In this article, we examine the principal legal and commercial risks arising from oil and gas decommissioning, including liability allocation, regulatory uncertainty, contractual fragmentation and execution risk. We also consider how these issues are developing not only in mature basins with longstanding regulatory frameworks such as the UK Continental Shelf, but increasingly across the Middle East and other emerging decommissioning markets where regulatory frameworks continue to evolve.
A uniquely complex risk environment
No two decommissioning projects are alike. Risk allocation depends heavily on the specific asset profile, location and contractual structure. However, certain categories of risk are consistently present:
These risks are amplified by the fact that decommissioning is an end of project lifecycle cost centre with no associated revenue stream, fundamentally altering the commercial dynamics compared to development or production phases. While such costs should, in principle, be fully anticipated and baked into project financials from the outset, in practice they are often underestimated or insufficiently provisioned at investment decision stage or in mid-life ownership changes, with the result that funding gaps and allocation disputes emerge at end of life.
Key pressure points
The most common areas of contention include:
These disputes are often exacerbated by misaligned incentives: operators seek cost control and regulatory compliance, while contractors face execution risk in complex and uncertain offshore environments.
Multi-party coordination risk
The fragmented nature of decommissioning projects creates systemic coordination risk with multiple contractors and subcontractors – there are complex chains of indemnities and liabilities and the potential for misalignment between project plans and contractual obligations. Breakdowns in coordination frequently give rise to interface disputes, particularly where delays cascade across the project.
Environmental and stakeholder pressures
External stakeholders increasingly influence decommissioning outcomes. For example, NGOs and local communities may challenge disposal methodologies, biodiversity impact and seabed restoration. These pressures can trigger disputes over who bears the cost of redesign or mitigation measures, particularly where requirements evolve mid‑project.
Timing and delay risk
Decommissioning programmes are highly sensitive to delay, for example due to weather conditions, technical uncertainty and supply chain constraints. Delays frequently result in disputes over extensions of time, liquidated damages and knock‑on impacts across the contractual chain.
The critical role of contractual architecture
Given the multi-tiered contractual structure, the importance of coherent and aligned dispute resolution mechanisms cannot be overstated. In practice back-to-back dispute clauses are essential to avoid fragmentation. Parties should aim for a single governing law, a common dispute forum and consistent procedural rules and timelines. Failure to align these provisions can result in parallel proceedings, inconsistent findings and significant duplication of cost and management time.
In larger projects, consideration should also be given to consolidation and joinder mechanisms, although these require careful drafting to ensure enforceability (particularly in arbitration). In addition, careful attention should be given to the attribution and continuity of liability where assets change hands during the project lifecycle, ensuring that responsibility is clearly allocated across successors, assigns and incoming operators to avoid gaps or unintended shifts in exposure.
Decommissioning in the UK
The Petroleum Act 1998 provides the statutory framework governing the decommissioning of offshore oil and gas infrastructure on the UK Continental Shelf (UKCS). The regime is administered by the Offshore Petroleum Regulator for Environment and Decommissioning (OPRED). Under this framework, owners of offshore installations and pipelines are required to submit a decommissioning programme when directed by the Secretary of State through a Section 29 notice. Section 29 notices are issued to a wide class of current and former participants (and their affiliates), requiring them to submit and carry out a decommissioning programme and once approved, those obligations are enforceable on a joint and several basis. This programme itself must identify all infrastructure to be removed or abandoned and set out the proposed decommissioning solution for each component.
As a result of the breadth of this “liability chain” and the ability to pursue parties long after divestment, Decommissioning Security Agreements (DSAs) are commonly entered into by joint venture (JV) participants on the UKCS, although not mandatory, to mitigate intra JV credit risk. Through these agreements JV participants agree how decommissioning liabilities will be shared and secured, and require each party to put in place financial security for its anticipated share of costs, such as through letters of credit, guarantees or trust arrangements.
Dispute risk areas in the execution of a decommissioning programme
Well Plugging & Abandonment (P&A): P&A remains the dominant cost driver and accounts for approximately 50% of total decommissioning expenditure. Delays in P&A programmes are a particular concern. Deferred activity has contributed to a backlog of wells and increasing cost pressure. Further, supply chain constraints, including availability of rigs, are driving higher day rates and execution risk.
This creates fertile ground for disputes, for example, over variations and scope changes; delay attribution; and escalation of contractor costs.
High costs and allocation disputes: With total UKCS costs now estimated at around £44 billion, cost allocation disputes are inevitable. JV partners frequently disagree on liability sharing mechanisms and contractors and operators often contest who bears unforeseen technical risks. In addition, decommissioning projects often encounter conditions that were not fully foreseeable at the contracting stage, raising difficult questions as to whether these constitute operator risk or contractor exposure.
Regulatory complexity
Decommissioning sits at the intersection of evolving regulatory regimes:
Regulatory evolution can create disputes where requirements change post-sanction or new environmental obligations alter the scope of work.
Scale of the challenge in the UK
The financial exposure associated with decommissioning is substantial and growing. Global liability exceeds $300 billion, with the UK, US Gulf of Mexico, Brazil and Norway representing a significant proportion of that exposure.
In the UKCS the total cost of decommissioning remaining infrastructure is currently estimated at around £44 billion (2024 prices). Approximately £27 billion is expected to be spent between 2023 and 2032. Annual expenditure is now running at £2–3 billion per annum, with £2.4 billion spent in 2024 alone. This is not merely a distant liability. The UK basin is already in what the NSTA describes as a “pivotal 10‑year period” for decommissioning activity.
At the operational level, the scale of activity is equally striking. A backlog of more than 500 wells has missed original decommissioning deadlines. Over 1,000 wells are expected to require P&A between 2026 and 2030.
These dynamics are driving increased urgency across operators and regulators, particularly as cost inflation, supply chain constraints and earlier cessation of production continue to accelerate decommissioning schedules.
The Energy Independence Bill 2006
The recently announced Energy Independence Bill 2026 is expected to formalise the government’s policy of issuing no new North Sea oil and gas licences, a shift that would accelerate the long‑term decline of the basin and, potentially, elevate the scale and urgency of future decommissioning activity. While the bill does not introduce new decommissioning rules, its broader direction — ending new licences and introducing transitional mechanisms — will influence when and how decommissioning takes place, peak decommissioning activity could move forward by five to ten years compared with pre‑2024 forecasts, with operators likely to bring forward cessation‑of‑production (CoP) dates for marginal fields. In the short term, companies are expected to begin preparing for earlier CoP, noting that many assets retain three to eight years of viable production. By the medium term, annual decommissioning expenditure is projected to rise significantly, with OGUK’s previous estimate of around £2 billion per year potentially increasing to £2.5–3 billion under an accelerated decline scenario.
Middle East and emerging decommissioning markets
Although decommissioning activity is most advanced in mature basins such as the UKCS, the Middle East and wider emerging markets are entering a preparatory phase in which legacy contractual structures will increasingly be tested against late-life asset realities.
Unlike jurisdictions such as the UK, where decommissioning is governed by a developed and established statutory framework and regulatory architecture, many Middle Eastern regimes do not yet contain comprehensive, stand-alone legislation specifically addressing offshore decommissioning. Instead, obligations are typically derived indirectly from a combination of petroleum legislation, environmental regulation and contractual instruments. This creates a less standardised and more contract-dependent risk environment.
Historically, many Host Government Granting Instruments (HGGIs), PSCs and concession agreements were negotiated at a time when end-of-life liabilities were either remote or not actively priced into project economics. As a result, older contractual frameworks are frequently silent, incomplete or ambiguous in relation to key issues, including:
As assets mature and decommissioning becomes imminent, these gaps create predictable areas of tension between state, operator and joint venture participants, in particular, disputes are likely to arise where parties disagree on whether decommissioning obligations are expressly assumed under the contract, implied through general standards of performance (such as “good international practice”) or capable of being expanded through evolving regulatory expectations.
In practice, the absence of a uniform regional framework increases reliance on contractual allocation of risk as the primary mechanism for managing decommissioning liability. While this creates flexibility for parties to structure bespoke arrangements, it also creates significant potential for future disputes, particularly where agreements fail to address late-life liabilities with sufficient precision or fail to anticipate regulatory evolution.
This is particularly acute where contracts require compliance with “good international petroleum industry practice” or similar standards, which are inherently dynamic and fact-sensitive. In civil law jurisdictions, where obligations of good faith may inform interpretation and performance (including, for example, under Article 246 of the UAE Civil Code), such open-textured standards may create uncertainty at the margins as to the content and evolution of performance obligations, particularly in the context of late-life decommissioning activities.
In any event, whether contractually mandated or otherwise, Operators in the region increasingly look to international standards and mature basin frameworks for guidance, including UNCLOS principles, OSPAR standards and aspects of the UK Petroleum Act regime. However, direct transplantation of North Sea approaches is not always straightforward given differing legal systems, state participation models and regulatory priorities.
As divestments accelerate and fields approach cessation of production, the Middle East is likely to see a rise in disputes concerning decommissioning liability allocation, security enforcement, cost allocation and residual environmental responsibility for ageing offshore infrastructure. In parallel, governments are expected to place increasing emphasis on abandonment planning, financial security mechanisms to deal with decommissioning obligations and long-term liability management as regulatory frameworks evolve.
Conclusion
Decommissioning represents a multi‑billion pound, high‑risk phase of the energy lifecycle, combining complex engineering with fragmented contractual frameworks and evolving regulation.
As activity accelerates, the risk of disputes will grow in parallel. Operators, contractors and investors who proactively structure contracts, align dispute mechanisms and anticipate regulatory evolution will be best placed to manage that risk.
In that sense, decommissioning is not simply an operational exercise. It is a legal and commercial battleground that will define the final value of many upstream investments.
Posted by: Emma Nierinck and Georgina Barlow
Return to News & Insights
