Home News & Insights Frustration and Building Safety Defects: No Easy Exit for Tenants
Into Nominee One Ltd v Study Group UK Ltd [2026] EWHC 1201 (TCC)
The High Court has for the first time provided important guidance on the limits of the frustration doctrine in the context of post‑Grenfell building safety defects. In Into Nominee, the tenant advanced what the Court recognised as a novel argument: that extensive internal and external fire safety defects, rendering a building unsafe and effectively unusable, had frustrated a long commercial lease.
The Court accepted that Voyager House, a bespoke residential educational facility for pre University age students contained serious and widespread internal and external fire safety defects and was not safe to occupy. The Court further accepted that the tenant Study Group was unlikely to be capable of lawfully occupying Voyager House for most or all of the remaining term. Even so, the Court granted summary judgment to the landlord on its rent arrears claim concluding that the frustration defence had no real prospect of success.
The decision turns not on the severity of the defects but on the contractual allocation of risk. The lease was in full repairing form and required the tenant, “whenever necessary”, to rebuild or replace the premises, an obligation which the Court held was sufficiently broad to extend to latent and serious defects, including those requiring wholesale reconstruction. This allocation was reinforced by an express clause excluding any warranty that the premises would be fit for the tenant’s intended use and the context of a prior agreement for lease where the tenant was to be provided with collateral warranties from the construction contractor, Balfour Beatty Construction.
Against that backdrop, the Court rejected the tenant’s argument that the lease had a “common purpose” of providing a safe and operable educational facility. Instead, it held that the contractual scheme – including the defects liability regime, the expectation of collateral warranties and the breadth of the repairing covenant – demonstrated that the parties had contemplated the possibility of latent defects and had allocated the consequences of those latent defects accordingly. In those circumstances, the inability to occupy the premises did not render performance “radically different” from the bargain struck.
An alternative argument based on changes in legislation following Grenfell also failed. The Court held that the relevant statutory developments did not fundamentally alter the tenant’s legal position; the building required remediation in any event, and the legislation merely sharpened the focus on existing obligations.
Importantly, however, the judgment should not be read as a blanket win for landlords. Its reasoning is closely tied to the particular terms of this lease and the way in which risk was allocated. The Court’s analysis makes clear that frustration remains a multi‑factorial inquiry, rooted in the terms, context and purpose of the contract.
A different outcome may well have been possible on a different factual or contractual footing. For example, where a lease contains more limited repairing obligations – particularly one that does not extend to rebuilding – or where responsibility for structural defects remains with the landlord, the analysis could shift materially. Similarly, the presence of an express or implied warranty of fitness for purpose, or rent suspension provisions extending beyond insured risks, might support a contention that safe and usable occupation was central to the bargain. The length of the unexpired term may also be critical: a shorter lease, coupled with a prolonged period of unusability, may more readily satisfy the “radically different” test.
The practical message is therefore a familiar but important one. For landlords, the decision underlines the protective value of wide repairing covenants, clear disclaimers of suitability and carefully constructed insurance regimes. For tenants, it is a reminder that full repairing leases may expose them to very significant latent defect risk, and that frustration will rarely provide an exit even in extreme circumstances.
Ultimately, Into Nominee reaffirms a central principle: where a lease has already allocated the risk of a supervening event, the doctrine of frustration will not be used to re‑write that allocation.
Gurbinder Grewal, Oliver Pickford and Anna Ball acted for Study Group.
Posted by: Gurbinder Grewal and Oliver Pickford
Return to News & Insights
