Once a topic of fiction, AI is now a part of our everyday lives, and its application to document-heavy construction, infrastructure and energy disputes provides a potentially transformative way of realising disclosure and document production efficiencies. The key question is whether the rules and procedures that govern these disputes are ready.

The Technology and Construction Court (TCC) has always been a forward-looking court. In 2013, it implemented a protocol for e-disclosure as part of its Court Users Guide. That protocol endorsed the use of predictive coding — an early frontrunner of modern AI tools — to reduce the cost and burden of disclosure by combining human decision-making with iterative machine learning.

Following its lead, the Chancery Division of the High Court in David Brown v BCA Trading Limited & Ors [2016] ordered the use of predictive coding for disclosure instead of traditional keyword searches. More recently, following the roll-out of the Disclosure Pilot Scheme, the Civil Procedure Rules adopted predictive coding as part of PD57AD. The use of AI in this way is not confined to the courts of England and Wales. According to a 2023 arbitration survey by colleagues at Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner LLP, 30% of respondents had used or permitted the use of AI in document review and production.

In both forums, there is, or will be, an emphasis on the parties collaborating or reaching agreement on matters such as which software, analytical techniques and coding strategies should be used. Under the Civil Procedure Rules, the court may give directions to this effect, and it is likely that tribunals would do the same in arbitration if the parties agreed to use AI.

Agreement on the process would, in the usual way, provide certainty and give parties the confidence to use AI productively. But what happens in arbitration where there is no agreement or order from the tribunal, yet one party adopts AI as part of document production? If discovered, there would be legitimate concerns about the reliability and accuracy of the results generated by the AI. This, in turn, may present questions around the fairness of the arbitration and could lead a party to resist enforcement of any award.

Similar criticisms may be levelled at traditional document production, where the risk of human error exists. However, quantifying errors resulting from the use of AI would be easier and faster to prove, especially where there is a clear audit trail to follow.

The media has already reported on the inappropriate use of AI in court proceedings, where fictitious authorities and opinions have been relied on, but only time will tell if the existing rules and procedures that govern disclosure and document production are ready for what’s to come.

Posted by: Oliver Pickford

Return to News & Insights
Loading