Home News & Insights Energy Disputes Series – Breaking Ground, Breaking Contracts
Managing Disputes in Energy Construction
Introduction
The energy sector is a cornerstone of global infrastructure and it continues to evolve rapidly in 2025. There is increasing demand for energy globally, with traditional oil and gas projects, as well as renewable and other alternative energy projects such as nuclear, critical to meeting this demand. The energy construction sector has always been a complex arena, and the current convergence of economic, technological, and regulatory shifts has contributed to creating an environment fraught with unique contractual challenges which increase the likelihood of disputes.
The array of construction projects in the energy sector is huge. In oil and gas, for example, drilling works, offshore platforms, gathering/production/storage facilities, and pipelines combine with large scale oil refineries, petrochemical plants, and LNG facilities. Outside of oil and gas, projects include large nuclear reactors, small modular reactors (SMR), offshore and onshore windfarms, solar projects, energy-from-waste plants, hydroelectric plants and hydrogen projects, together with grid infrastructure, battery storage and cable laying. Each project or technology has its own distinct challenges, and the disputes that arise are as varied as the projects themselves.
However, some common themes do emerge. This article explores some of the key issues and disputes faced by stakeholders in the energy construction sector and offers insights into navigating these challenges effectively.
Design Risk
Large scale energy projects very often carry with them significant design risk. There are a number of reasons for this. For example, as new and innovative energy generation solutions emerge, new, technologies must be designed for and executed at scale, usually within short timescales. The proliferation of alternative technological solutions often means that design development takes place in parallel with project execution, leading to risks in terms of project duration and cost. By way of example, the offshore wind market has been in a state of continual development of turbine sizes and foundation philosophies, including the introduction of floating solutions. In oil and gas, projects can involve the updating/extension of existing facilities (such as an existing oil refinery upgrade project) where the existing facilities are intended to stay operational throughout the construction project. This can result in difficulties both with designing the upgraded works to interact properly with the existing facilities, and also in establishing installation methodologies and scheduling that enables the new facilities to be installed without disrupting the ongoing activities of the plant. Often, depending on the nature of the project and how close it must be to the energy source, local geography itself can be challenging and have an impact on the progress of the construction project.
Contracts should aim to clearly delineate responsibilities for design adequacy and address potential liabilities arising from design errors or omissions. Incorporating provisions for independent design reviews or adopting Building Information Modelling (BIM) tools can help mitigate disputes.
A significant number of energy infrastructure projects are carried out under lump-sum contracts, and uncertainties, errors, or simply design development issues in the design phase can lead to cost overruns, delays, and disputes during execution of the project. It is important for such issues to be addressed quickly and collaboratively as soon as they arise, in order to mitigate as much as possible any delay caused by needing to review or revise designs.
Technology
Given the current pace of technological development combined with the timescales involved from start to finish of a large energy infrastructure project, the technology earmarked for use in the project may move on before or during the construction phase, necessitating changes to the project plan. Parties should consider at the outset how such advancements will be dealt with, and should consider including provisions that provide for the incorporation of technological development in certain circumstances, as well allocating responsibility for payment for incorporation.
New technologies generally come with a greater risk of further work being required to construct, install or commission the works than might have been anticipated at the outset. Ensuring that such risks have been properly accounted for and allocated in the contract (including price and schedule) at the start can be valuable in reducing the scope for disputes over delays and cost-overruns later in the project.
Throughout both the construction and subsequent life of the project, the integration of advanced technologies, such as automation and data management systems, is reshaping contract and project management. Used properly, these tools can enhance operational efficiency but also require procedures and contracts to address data security, version control, and audit trails.
Finally, as a practical matter in respect of disputes, rapid technological developments can result in it becoming more difficult to find appropriate experts to assist a Tribunal or Court. To the extent that a technical dispute does arise, identification of an appropriate, independent expert should be considered as a priority.
Inflation and Cost Uncertainty
Inflation and fluctuating costs remain a significant factor impacting energy construction projects. Inflation is a particular risk in energy projects, which are typically long-term, undertaken in a range of challenging jurisdictions and rely on a variety of different procurement items from key, long-lead, specialised equipment to simpler materials, procured on shorter-lead times but more exposed to short-term price fluctuations. Rising material and labour costs, as well as fluctuating supply chain prices, create difficulties in establishing fixed-price contracts that may apply for a number of years. Contractors and clients can face delays in procurement due to pricing uncertainties or supply restrictions, leading to project inefficiencies.
For large, complex, energy projects cost uncertainty poses a significant risk, as longer construction times can mean potentially significant cost overruns. Parties should consider these issues at the outset and include provision for who will bear these risks in the Contract. In recent years, contractors have often borne the larger share of this risk. However, the current economic climate is particularly uncertain, and as a result these risks may be too high for a contractor to take on and manage, at least entirely. One way of managing this risk is to include a costs escalation clause in the contract. This clause should express the ‘trigger’ for escalation, which costs can be escalated and how any escalation is to be calculated. In the absence of an escalation clause, the contractor is left with few options other than to try to recover the increased costs by making a claim, which could be costly and difficult to prove.
Supply Chain Disruption
In addition to the above, the specialist equipment needed to complete complex energy construction projects is particularly vulnerable to supply chain disruption, caused by events such as international conflicts, natural disasters, sanctions and pandemics, all of which have occurred (in some instances concurrently) over the last few years.
Supply chain disruption can result in increases in disputes, price escalation and variations. This can lead to parties becoming involved in contractual disputes around concepts such as frustration, force majeure or change in circumstances – noting that such provisions may not be the same throughout the supply chain, leading to different results under different contracts as regards the same set of underlying circumstances. Contracts should clearly provide which party is responsible for the time and costs of these situations, but as with price increases, some flexibility in the contractual risk allocation can pay dividends in terms of reducing the scope for delays and disputes during project execution.
Regulatory Compliance
The energy sector operates within a complex regulatory framework. Adhering to international and local regulations requires meticulous contract management. Non-compliance can result in legal disputes, project delays, and financial penalties. In particular in energy projects, the roles and responsibilities of the employer and contractor in this regard can be challenging to navigate and can give rise to disagreements and disputes. Consideration should be given to drafting project and compliance-specific clauses that anticipate regulatory changes, particularly in renewable energy projects where regulations often evolve rapidly in response to shifting policy. Contracts should account for the likelihood of such changes by incorporating flexible mechanisms to manage delay or disruption arising from regulatory developments or permitting issues. This is especially important where neither party is necessarily at fault, but project progress is nonetheless affected. In addition, bespoke provisions should reflect the stringent environmental standards typically applicable in this sector, ensuring that compliance obligations are clearly allocated and realistically achievable.
Interface risk
Complex energy construction projects often involve complex interfaces between different works package contractors. This can give rise to interface and coordination issues, particularly around access to work areas or the completion of preceding works. The coordination and management of multiple works package contractors is often undertaken by the employer, but in reality this requires significant coordination and collaboration among all the various parties. Employers should ensure that sufficient contract and project management expertise (and time) is dedicated to these aspects, so as to avoid delays and costs issues.
Energy construction projects also typically have numerous practical interfaces, including for example grid connections, water supply and waste disposal that have to be managed with multiple stakeholders as separate moving parts to the main project. Contracts should include provisions for real-time collaboration and dispute resolution mechanisms to mitigate risks.
Given that disputes could potentially involve multiple parties, effective dispute resolution mechanisms, are essential to pre-empt conflicts arising from miscommunication or misaligned expectations but must be considered carefully on a project-wide basis to ensure the right mechanisms are used for each particular case.
In this regard, parties have options at the contracting stage to try and manage such issues more effectively. For example, one option is to draft a separate arbitration agreement that sits on top of all the project contracts and uses one set of rules, one procedure and one arbitral tribunal, and provides for joinder or consolidation as the case may be. Another option is to ensure that joinder and/or consolidation clauses are included in back-to-back contracts. Different options have different potential benefits or downsides and it is therefore important to consider these issues on a case-by-case basis to ensure the dispute resolution mechanisms are appropriate.
Conclusion
The disputes landscape for construction projects in the energy sector is becoming increasingly intricate, with numerous factors giving rise to problems and therefore the risk of disputes. Design risks, regulatory compliance and interface risks are well known risks that have been features of energy infrastructure construction for a while. However, these are now complicated further by the fast pace of technological development and global issues around supply chain disruption and cost uncertainty. By addressing challenges proactively and collaboratively, and leveraging advanced tools and strategies, stakeholders can ensure the successful delivery of projects and seek to minimise formal disputes. In the event of a dispute, proper consideration of the issues raised above from the outset can play an important role in resolving the dispute as efficiently and reliably as possible.
Mantle Law has significant experience advising on large scale energy infrastructure projects and disputes, so please contact us with any further queries.
Posted by: Georgina Barlow and Alexander Slade
Return to News & Insights
