The recent news that the Australian contractor CGU has decided to demobilise and walk away from the multi-billion dollar new Sydney M6 motorway after being blighted with sinkholes raises the importance once again of managing the risk of ground conditions.

Disputes surrounding the responsibility of adverse ground conditions (also referred to as site or physical conditions) is not new, but with careful consideration of the contract and practical steps, risk can be appropriately managed.

What are Ground Conditions and Why are they Important?

In broad terms ground condition can be naturally occurring or man-made and refer to soil conditions, geology, hydrology and any contamination of the ground at the site location of the Project, which for road networks, tunnels or pipelines, for example, could be extensive.

A common denominator amongst all construction and engineering related contracts is that they are built on the ground (and for infrastructure projects will often require underground structures, such as tunnelling in the Sydney motorway project). As such, it should follow that significant attention is given to the risk of adverse ground conditions and importantly allocation of that risk. In turn this can minimise the impact of discovering adverse ground conditions during the works – such as changes to working methods, more costly materials, design changes and programming delays and disruption. This will likely result in claims from the Contractor for extensions of time and additional costs and developers having to explain to funders why the project is likely to far exceed its expected budget and timescale.

  1. What does the Contract state?

Perhaps it goes without saying that the contract is key and that clear contractual wording is paramount when it comes to allocation of risk However not all contracts are created equal and depend upon the standard form used, as well as any amendments. Further, bespoke contracts must be combed through carefully to determine risk allocation and the existence of a ground conditions clause at all.

As regards standard form contracts some allocate risk to the Contractor, for example the FIDIC Silver book 2017. However, the Yellow and Red Books 2017 (and pre 2017) set out a procedure to be followed by the Contractor to claim time and/or money if it believes there are ‘physical conditions’ that are ‘unforeseeable’ that will have an ‘adverse effect’ on progress and/or increase cost of the works.

In a similar vein NEC 3 & 4 allows the Contractor to claim time and money as a result of physical/ground conditions that a were not reasonably foreseeable at the date it entered into the contract. Importantly the Contractor is also presumed to have considered site information and other information available to it whether in the public domain, from a visual inspection or other information that an experienced Contractor would be expected to take into account.

The recent JCT D&B 2024 also allows the Contractor to claim time and money in respect of specific ground issues, such as contamination and discovery of asbestos, unless they were already identified in contract documents. This differs from earlier versions of the JCT Contracts which do not expressly deal with responsibility for ground conditions (with the exception of the 2016 Major Projects form, which is unchanged in its 2024 form), meaning the common law steps in to determine that the risk sits with the Contractor.

  1. Site Investigation and Foreseeability of Ground Conditions

As can be seen the contract forms can vary widely so knowing your contractual obligations is of utmost importance, including what site investigations are being undertaken and by whom.

The question of foreseeability (or what is unforeseeable) is a theme running through most of the standard form contracts. What is reasonably foreseeable has perhaps unsurprisingly been the subject of disputes with contractors being held to a high standard, particularly in the context of site investigations/information.

Ultimately, regardless of whether the Employer has undertaken site investigations or provided its own site data, a Contractor should always undertake its own investigations to verify information to satisfy itself as to the potential ground condition risks.

This is also the approach advocated in Obrascon Huarte Lain v HM Attorney General for Gibraltar[1] in which the court was asked to decide whether certain ground conditions would have been reasonably foreseeable by an experienced contractor (pursuant to the FIDIC yellow book). In this case ground contamination arose from land used as a former military site and its use as an airfield, and specifically a rifle range where the road and tunnel was to be built. The Court of Appeal found that an experienced contractor would make its own assessment of all available data, drawing on its expertise and experience, and not simply accept someone else’s interpretation.

The decision was followed by the TCC in Van Oord UK v Allseas UK[2] in which it held that an experienced Contractor should fill any missing gaps in information provided to it and the fact that ground conditions may not be uniform across the site does not make them unforeseeable for an experienced contractor.

  1. The Employer’s Disclaimer

It is not unusual to see a clause that excludes the Employer from any liability for inaccuracies etc in the site information provided and that the Contractor is to satisfy itself as to the same. Employers tend to include such clauses to protect themselves even though there is no implied warranty at common law as to the accuracy of the Employer’s documents. But in the absence of such a clause, a Contractor might bring a claim for misrepresentation, based on the inaccuracy of the site information provided, albeit this is not straightforward.

  1. The Contractor’s Approach

Ultimately a Contractor should plan for the worst case scenario, seeking to reduce its risk by conducting its own thorough investigations, pricing the risk, reflecting the risk in its programme and negotiating contractual amendments to split, or clarify, the risk allocation.

Overall, responsibility for ground conditions remains a contentious negotiation point in many contracts, but it is vitally important for the parties to be aware of the risk allocation and what it means for them should adverse ground conditions be encountered.

[1] Obrascon Huarte Lain SA v Her Majesty’s Attorney General for Gibraltar [2015] EWCA Civ 712

[2] Van Oord UK and Sicim Roadbridge v Allseas UK [2015] EWHC 3074 (TCC)

Posted by: Lucy Bushell

Return to News & Insights
Loading