The Court grapples with this issue in the recent decision of Mace Construct Ltd v Baltic Investment Holdings Ltd [2026] EWHC 976 (TCC)

Last week, Mr Adrian Williamson KC, sitting as a deputy Judge of the Technology and Construction Court, rendered a Part 8 Judgment on Tuesday 28 April 2026 in relation to a dispute between Mace and Baltic Investment Holdings (“Baltic”) concerning ongoing refurbishment works at The Baltic Exchange, a listed building located in the heart of the City of London. Mantle Law acted for Mace (the successful Claimant) and instructed David Streatfeild-James KC and Mathias Cheung at Atkin Chambers.

The judgment in Mace Construct Ltd v Baltic Investment Holdings Ltd [2026] EWHC 976 (TCC) provides welcome clarification of how schedules of derogations – commonly used in the industry – should be interpreted where the parties have sought to qualify or supplement the contract conditions to reflect the practical realities of the project at the outset. The decision offers guidance on how a Schedule of Derogations can qualify contractual design risk under an amended JCT Design and Build 2016 form. The focus of the Part 8 claim was the status and effect of the Schedule of Derogations and related Tender Clarifications, and how they interact with the contractor’s design obligations under the JCT contract. The Court granted the majority of the Declarations sought by Mace, finding that the Schedule of Derogations must be given effect to define, qualify and/or clarify the contractual allocation of risk and responsibilities for design.

The Contract

Under the amended JCT D&B 2016 Contract, Mace had agreed to carry out and complete the design of the Works. The amended Conditions provided, among other things that Mace

“shall be responsible for obtaining all consents necessary for the carrying out and completion of the Works (to the extent that these have not already been obtained) and shall comply with such consents and for the discharge of any conditions or reserved matters contained within the planning permission(s) for the Works without any adjustment to the Contract Sum and the Contractor shall not have nor make any claim for an extension of time under clause 2.25 or for loss and expense under clause 4.20“; and

“shall be fully responsible and liable in all respects for the entire design of the Works regardless of whether it had been (a) prepared by or on behalf of Mace and/or (b) carried out on or before the date of the Contract”.

The Contractor’s Proposals included a Schedule of Derogations, which listed out a number of items of work and included the following terms:

“(1) Mace Construct Ltd are unable to take design responsibility, associated risk of any discrepancies, inconsistencies and inadequacy of the below listed items until the period of initial design development is complete on the 2nd February 2024, 6 working weeks from anticipated contract execution date (08 December 2023)”; and

“(2) Once the derogations listed in this document have been concluded and approval from all parties obtained, and formal instruction received Mace Construct Ltd will take design responsibility on the items listed above. Mace Construct Ltd will take design responsibility, excluding planning approval from the 2nd of February 2024, 6 working weeks from anticipated contract execution date (08 December 2023)”.

The Court’s Decision

In a previous adjudication, the adjudicator Mr Nigel Davies had found that the Schedule of Derogations (incorporated into the Contract as part of the Contractor’s Proposals) did not override or modify the JCT Conditions or Schedule of Amendments and did not defer, suspend or re‑allocate Mace’s underlying design risk. Using the Part 8 procedure, Mace asked the Court to review and finally determine that legal point of construction of the Contract.

The Court disagreed with the adjudicator that the Schedule of Derogations could not displace the design obligations generally set out in the Conditions and Schedule of Amendments and finally determined various fundamental points of principle relevant to entitlements which had been decided in the adjudication.

  1. Schedule of Derogations prevails

Mace argued that the Schedule of Derogations served to limit Mace’s design risk in respect of the items set out therein, relying on the wording at paragraphs (1) and (2) of the Schedule of Derogations referred to above, in particular “Once the derogations listed in this document have been concluded and approval from all parties obtained, and formal instruction received Mace Construct Ltd will take design responsibility on the items listed above”. [emphasis added]

Baltic contended the Schedule of Derogations could not and did not have such effect, since it was contrary to the general design obligations described in the Schedule of Amendments. Baltic relied on amended JCT Condition 1.3, a bespoke version of the JCT’s standard ‘hierarchy’ clause, which provided:

“[…] Nothing contained in any other Contract Document or any Framework Agreement, irrespective of their terms, shall override or modify the Agreement or these Conditions or the Schedule of Amendments.

In the event of any discrepancy between (a) the Agreement, the Recitals, the Articles, the Contract Particulars, the Conditions and/or the Schedule and (b) the Schedule of Amendments, then the provisions of the Schedule of Amendments shall prevail.

In the event of any discrepancy between (a) the Schedule of Derogations and (b) the Employer’s Requirements, the Schedule of Derogations shall prevail.”

The Judge started from the proposition that the word ‘derogation’ was to be given its plain and ordinary meaning, from the Oxford English Dictionary [23] “the partial abrogation or repeal of a law, contract, treaty, legal right, etc.” and that “It seems to me clear that the parties were agreeing, in relation to the listed items, that Mace’s obligations were to be in some way limited.”

The Judge considered at [30] to [32] that there was no discrepancy between the Schedule of Derogations and the Schedule of Amendments on which Condition 1.3 could ‘bite’. The Schedule of Derogations did not in effect override the Schedule of Amendments, but instead supplemented it “by clarifying how and in what way Mace is to perform the obligations and undertake its design responsibility in relation to the listed items”.

The Judge concluded at [31] that even if there were a discrepancy “it is the Schedule of Derogations, called up and referenced in the Schedule of Amendments, which creates the Initial Scope of Works regime” and accordingly “… the Schedule of Derogations would prevail”. In doing so the Judge rejected Baltic’s argument that the Schedule of Derogations clashed with the ‘hierarchy’ set out in amended Condition 1.3 and that the Conditions ‘trumped’ the Schedule of Derogations’.

The decision confirms that a properly drafted Schedule of Derogations can operate as an effective limitation of a party’s design obligations, without being negated by hierarchy wording in the JCT form or Schedule of Amendments.

  1. Mace only took on design responsibility for the derogation items once the derogations had been concluded

In assessing the status and effect the Schedule of Derogations, the Court considered the purpose of the Schedule of Derogations in light of other documents such as the derogations programme and noted at [25] that

“[T]he parties clearly intended that there would be a process of to and fro on the design of these items, which would be concluded with the issue of an instruction to Mace. The Derogations Programme_V3 (as referred to in the definition of “Initial Scope of Works”) set out a series of steps for each of the listed items. In each case, the steps led up to the provision of an instruction to Mace.” 

In dismissing Baltic and Mr Davies’ interpretation of the Contract, the Court noted that it would have been “an odd result” [24] to give effect to the Schedule of Derogations only to the extent that it did not seek to limit design liability, which would have required one to ignore the express words “Once the derogations listed in this document have been concluded… Mace Construct Ltd will take design responsibility on the items listed above”.

This decision serves as an important reminder that as a matter of contractual construction, the English Courts will seek to give effect to the entirety of the agreement negotiated and concluded between the Parties, and will be slow to favour interpretations that would render an entire section of the agreement ineffective.


See also: The Use of ‘Commercial Amendments’ and Risk of Contractual Dystopia

Posted by: Alice Andreoletti

Return to News & Insights
Loading