Home News & Insights Understanding Construction Risks in Nuclear Power Plant Projects
Understanding Construction Risks in Nuclear Power Plant Projects
The global demand for power is ever-increasing, driven by population growth, industrialisation, increasing electrification (for example, electrical vehicles), and the increasing reliance on digital technologies. A key recent contributor is the rapid growth of generative AI, which has significantly accelerated the need for large-scale data centres and in turn, energy. Demand for power resulting directly from data centres is expected to grow more than 160% by 2030, compared to recent levels.[i] This increase in demand has led to a strengthening in investor confidence as regards the future growth of electricity demands; supported by ‘big tech’ seeking low-carbon reliable energy sources.
As such, there is renewed focus on the role of nuclear energy.
While other energy sources will continue to meet the majority of global needs, nuclear energy will inevitably be required to meet part of the shortfall, particularly during the global energy transition period, when renewable resources alone are unable to satisfy the world’s increasing energy requirements. Presently, there are more than 60 nuclear reactors under construction worldwide, with over 80 further reactors planned, and more than 300 proposed to be built, which will assist in meeting the increased demand for power.[ii] As well as consideration for new larger-scale reactors, there is also a noticeable uptick in conversations around the de-mothballing of recently retired nuclear generators; for example, there are plans to reauthorise the operation of Palisades Nuclear Plant in Michigan, which ceased operation in 2022, and for the reopening of the Three Mile Island nuclear power plant in 2028 after shutdown in 2019.[iii]
These projects are complex, and come with particular risks in their construction. We provide our thoughts on a number of the key risks.
The Contractual Structure
Effective risk allocation is critical in nuclear projects, as in any complex infrastructure development, and must be clearly documented across the project’s contractual suite. Nuclear developments typically involve a broad range of contracts beyond the principal engineering, procurement and construction (EPC) agreement. These may include early operation support service agreements, long-term engineering arrangements, maintenance service contracts, fuel supply and handling agreements, nuclear liability and insurance arrangements, regulatory compliance support agreements, decommissioning and waste management contracts, training and knowledge transfer agreements and grid connection or power purchase agreements. Each plays a distinct role in supporting the technical, regulatory, and commercial lifecycle of a nuclear facility and must be carefully coordinated to ensure consistency, compliance and effective risk management throughout the project.
Whether parties adopt a single main engineering and construction contract or a multi-contract structure – both common approaches in nuclear projects – standard form agreements such as FIDIC or NEC provide a useful starting point. However, in their unamended form, these contracts can prove to be inadequate for the complexity, regulatory oversights and long-term risk profile of nuclear developments. Careful and forensic amendment is essential to ensure that project-specific risks are appropriately allocated, clearly articulated and fully understood by all parties involved. This is particularly important in the nuclear context, where misallocation or ambiguity can have significant technical, legal and financial consequences.
Given the complexity of nuclear projects, characterised by evolving regulatory frameworks, discretionary approvals and advancing technologies, variations to the scope of works are inevitable over the project lifecycle. It is therefore critical that the variation provisions within the contract are structured to allow instructions to be implemented efficiently, cost-effectively and, where possible, without disrupting progress. Standard form contracts are typically amended to allow the employer to instruct the contractor to proceed with a variation immediately, without waiting for the variation to be fully priced or formally agreed. This approach ensures continuity of works while commercial terms are finalised, balancing the need for flexibility with the imperative to maintain programme certainty.
Warranties and indemnities are often heavily negotiated in nuclear project contracts, particularly in relation to fitness for purpose and service life obligations. This is especially the case where the contractor has not been engaged to carry out the detailed design or to define key technical specifications. In such scenarios, contractors may resist broad warranties and seek to qualify their obligations accordingly. In parallel, contractors commonly seek indemnities in respect of nuclear incidents and the unique risks arising from radiological exposure, contamination and regulatory liabilities. The allocation of such risks requires careful drafting, given the complex interface between contractual obligations, statutory liability regimes and insurance coverage.
Contractors will often seek greater entitlements to an extension of time due to extended lead times in procurement, regulatory interventions and design assessments that might necessitate modifications and additional testing.
When issues arise on nuclear projects, it is critical to have robust and tailored dispute resolution mechanisms in place which are capable of resolving disputes efficiently and effectively, ideally as and when they occur. Building in sensible dispute escalation stages, including for example standing dispute avoidance / adjudication boards (DAABs), or equivalent are increasingly used to facilitate early resolution and minimise project disruption. However, reference to formal dispute resolution procedures should be considered as a last resort and it is preferable to prevent disputes through proactive contract management. This includes clear risk allocation (as discussed above), well-defined reporting and notification procedures and the appointment of experienced and reputable employer representatives who are empowered to make timely decisions.
There is also a growing trend toward incorporating incentive-based contractual mechanisms that reward successful performance, rather than relying solely on penalties for delay or cost overruns. These models are designed to promote collaboration, encourage productivity and incentivise value engineering to reduce overall project cost. This is particularly important in the context of complex, long-duration nuclear developments.
Experienced Supply Chain
Recently, it appears that there is a general shortening of nuclear power plant project delivery times, likely due to the greater experience of stakeholders in such projects.[iv] However, as with any mega-project, there remains a significant risk that progress may be impacted by one of a large number of variables such that a nuclear project does not complete as-planned and, in turn, results in significant losses and the inability to generate income from the reactor as anticipated.[v]
Whilst this is a risk in any large energy project, there are elements of nuclear projects that increase the likelihood of delay. Nuclear projects face potential delays as a result of intense regulatory scrutiny, first-of-a-kind design risks, and nuclear-grade quality assurance requirements. The supply chain is generally narrow, politically sensitive and vulnerable to long-lead procurement failures such as large pressure vessels or instrumentation and control platforms. Coupled with public sensitivity and developing safety standards, these factors make nuclear delivery schedules particularly vulnerable to delay and legally complex.
One way to minimise the impact of delays is to ensure that that the right supply chain is engaged including, among others, the most appropriate and skilled contractors, subcontractors suppliers and consultants, with the requisite and, importantly, recent knowledge in delivering such projects. Engaging an experienced supply chain assists in mitigating against potential issues, as experience should ensure that complications are identified sooner rather than later. Additionally, consideration should be given to the early engagement of nuclear-specialised consultants (particularly with experience in the relevant jurisdiction, if available) to enhance the knowledge and understanding of the regulatory regime and applicable requirements, which may assist in establishing a more realistic project schedule, as well as the selection and supervision of vendors in the supply chain.
The engagement of an experienced team, in what is becoming an increasingly busy sector, will likely involve higher costs. Such expenditure should be considered in the context of the cost of delays or sub-standard works.
That being said, there are a relatively small number of specialist contractors, subcontractors and suppliers with nuclear-specific experience and so it may be a case of drawing together whatever team is available and within budget. To compound this, a lack of nuclear project specific knowledge may be more impactful now than ever before due to the increase in scale, scope and complexity of nuclear power plants arising from, to name a few, the requirement for reactors with much great capacity and significant regulatory and safety procedures. Even for those parties with specific nuclear industry experience, there can be significant gaps in the approvals and funding for new nuclear projects in certain jurisdictions, which results in a loss of knowledge and expertise in the supply chain due to the period of time that has elapsed since previous projects were executed.
Planning & Design Stage
It is particularly important for nuclear construction projects to undergo a comprehensive design and planning phase to ensure compliance with international and local regulatory requirements, contractual specifications and any specific employer requirements. In addition to contractual requirements, nuclear projects must comply with national and international regulations designed to ensure safety, efficiency and environmental protection. Ensuring that the project meets the relevant jurisdictional and international regulations is essential. In certain jurisdictions (such as France or Japan) where there have been a number of nuclear projects, there are well-developed nuclear frameworks with which compliance will be mandatory. Conversely, in jurisdictions with a lack of familiarity with the development of nuclear projects, challenges may arise for suppliers when dealing with regulatory bodies that are relatively new to, for example, the approval processes for nuclear projects which may lead to delays and roadblocks in acquiring approvals.
In any event, given length of time it can take to attain the requisite approvals and the lengthy construction phase on nuclear projects, there is a risk that regulatory requirements may evolve during the lifetime of nuclear project construction. Stakeholders should stay informed of any regulatory changes and ensure that the contract makes provision for accommodating potential changes as well as clearly allocating risk for any changes to project, national and international regulations or laws.
During the planning phase, the parties should consider whether the project is a “first of a kind” (FOAK) project where it is a one-off project with custom designs or a “nth of a kind” (NOAK) where it is essentially a repeat of previously completed projects. Generally, NOAK projects result in considerable costs savings compared to a FOAK project and issues which may have arisen on a previous FOAK project will have been made known and, with the correct identification and planning, may be avoided in future projects thus lowering the risk and ultimately the cost.
Dispute Management
Drafting a practical and robust dispute resolution clause in a contract is of paramount importance, particularly for nuclear projects. Such clauses not only provide a structured approach to resolving disagreements but can also help to maintain the contractual relationship between parties, preventing or at least effectively managing the escalation of conflicts.
Parties should consider a tiered approach to resolving conflicts through the use of senior management, expert determinations or standing DAABs, ultimately with the final resolution in formal dispute proceedings such as arbitration or court. To the extent that parties opt for a tiered provision, care should be taken to ensure that its provisions are carefully and fully complied with, in order to avoid the risk of smaller, ‘satellite’ disputes regarding compliance with dispute resolution terms of the contract.
To avoid ongoing disputes which can lead to a breakdown in the commercial relationship, the use of DAABs may be effective, particularly in highly complex projects with a long construction period. Standing DAABs can address and resolve conflicts as they arise during the project stage, which may assist in the prompt resolution of issues on the project and reduce any impact on progress or completion. It would also be possible to ensure that the DAAB have nuclear specific expertise given the highly technical nature of the project and therefore, by association, the disputes.
Whatever the dispute resolution mechanism, it is important to ensure accurate record keeping throughout the project and following its completion, particularly information prepared by individuals who, as the project progresses may leave the project prior to completion.
Conclusion
Nuclear projects are highly complex and with such come with their own unique risks, to which careful consideration should be given from the outset. Engaging an experienced supply chain, ensuring an appropriate allocation of risks in contracts and undergoing comprehensive planning and design stages (possibly with the involvement of nuclear specific consultants) will go some way towards protecting parties from encountering significant issues during the course of the project. Unfortunately, all too often, projects of this scale result in disputes and, therefore, ensuring an effective dispute resolution mechanism is included in the contract to resolve issues efficiently and in a cost-effective manner is essential.
Note
Mantle Law has experience advising on large scale infrastructure projects, including nuclear and other specialised energy projects and so please contact us with any further queries.
[i] https://www.goldmansachs.com/insights/articles/is-nuclear-energy-the-answer-to-ai-data-centers-power-consumption Last accessed 23 May 2025.
[ii] https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/current-and-future-generation/plans-for-new-reactors-worldwide#:~:text=About%2065%20reactors%20are%20under,by%20old%20plants%20being%20retired Last accessed 23 May 2025.
[iii] https://www.npr.org/2024/09/20/nx-s1-5120581/three-mile-island-nuclear-power-plant-microsoft-ai; https://principia.es/en/mothballed-nuclear-plants-coming-back-to-life/ Last accessed 23 May 2025.
[iv] https://world-nuclear.org/images/articles/REPORT-Lesson-learning-in-Nuclear-Construction.pdf Last accessed 23 May 2025
[v] https://world-nuclear.org/images/articles/REPORT-Lesson-learning-in-Nuclear-Construction.pdf Last accessed 23 May 2025
Posted by: Emma Nierinck and Andrew Primett
Return to News & Insights
