Home News & Insights Manmade Island Projects in the Middle East: Risk versus Reward
Manmade Island Projects in the Middle East: Risk versus Reward
INTRODUCTION
The construction of manmade islands has become a prominent feature of the Middle Eastern development landscape in recent years with no signs of slowing. These ambitious projects present many exciting opportunities across the tourism, real estate and infrastructure sectors of the countries where they are undertaken. At the same time, these mega-projects also pose significant legal, financial and technical challenges in their planning and execution. This article explores some of those challenges, as well as the benefits and future potential of manmade islands, with a focus on the risks that contracting parties should carefully consider.
A BRIEF HISTORY OF MANMADE ISLANDS AND LAND RECLAMATION
Whilst the Middle East has advanced the scale and ambition of manmade island projects, the technique of land reclamation predates the region’s adoption of it. The Netherlands, for example, has long been a global pioneer, having added as much as 1,650 km² to its landmass in the 20th century alone.[1] Globally, land reclamation has been used to accommodate rising populations, develop and expand port capacity (both sea and air), increase agricultural farmland and to facilitate urban and infrastructure expansion.
The Middle Eastern Experience
In pursuit of economic diversification and strategic visions such as ‘Dubai Vision 2030’ and ‘Qatar National Vision 2030’, several Middle Eastern states have turned to manmade islands as an option for continued expansion. The flagship example remains Dubai’s Palm Jumeirah, completed in 2007, which proved the potential of visionary architecture and engineering to reshape coastlines and boost economies. Palm Jumeirah has amply demonstrated that, with the vision, thorough planning and execution, the development of manmade islands can prove extremely successful in elevating a country’s construction and tourism sectors and ultimately its economy.
A further example is found in Qatar, which launched and successfully executed The Pearl, built on a former pearl diving site[2] and designed to resemble a string of pearls, merging modern, iconic construction with Qatar’s rich cultural heritage.
Middle East Demand: Current and Future Projects
The success of Palm Jumeirah, coupled with an increasing demand for coastal real estate and leisure destinations, has ultimately served as a springboard, with several other manmade island projects either having been completed or already underway in the Middle East (with KSA and UAE leading the charge). Key projects include:
Given the Netherland’s pioneering technical contributions to land reclamation, it comes as no surprise that Dutch companies continue to provide expertise in the construction of manmade islands in the Middle East, particularly in dredging and maintenance, alongside a host of local and international contractors and experts.
Methods of Land Reclamation
There are several methods of carrying out land reclamation including the dry method, hydraulic reclamation, hydraulic filling and sand spreading. The method chosen for any particular project will depend upon a number of variables such as soil composition and seabed topography.[3]
In the Middle East, hydraulic filling is commonly employed. This involves dredging sand from the seabed at various offshore sites and transporting it to designated locations where the sand is deposited by being pumped into the sea to form the desired land shape outline. The reclaimed land is then left to ‘settle’ before further development work on the new landmass begins.
CHALLENGES AND RISKS
As with the development of any mega-project, manmade island projects are not without risk. These risks are varied and overlapping, spanning the technical, financial, environmental and legal sectors. We explore some of these risks, and their mitigation, below.
Technical Risks and Advances in Engineering
Among the most serious risks are those that are geotechnical in nature: subsidence, soil instability, rising sea levels and structural vulnerabilities. Innovations in technology allow for some of these risks to be mitigated. These include stronger breakwaters and the process of vibro-compaction, which accelerates the settlement process, significantly aiding with achieving ambitious completion dates.
To avoid or mitigate these technical risks, developers should engage with specialist geotechnical consultants early in the project lifecycle to conduct detailed site investigations and modelling. Where new engineering techniques or materials are being employed, proper trials and prototype testing can help validate design assumptions. It is also prudent to incorporate design margins for environmental changes such as sea level rise and to maintain flexibility in design to accommodate evolving best practices in construction and to ensure climate resilience.
Dredging Complexities
Perhaps one of the more fundamental processes involved in land reclamation projects, dredging can be susceptible to delay and disruption caused by breakdown of equipment, lack of availability of replacement equipment, shortages in the highly skilled labour required to operate complex machinery and unknown seabed conditions. Owing to the sheer scale of some of the manmade islands in the region, dredging can take a considerable amount of time, and can also be prone to setbacks caused by adverse weather and strong sea currents. On large-scale sites, these delays can cascade, impacting broader timelines.
To mitigate dredging-related risks, project planners should carry out detailed geophysical surveys during the feasibility and design stages to ascertain seabed conditions and plan appropriate dredging techniques. Contingency plans should be in place for equipment breakdown, including agreements for on-call specialist machinery and labour. Contracts should clearly allocate weather risk and include realistic timeline buffers. Adopting real-time monitoring can help flag delays early and allow for course corrections before any impacts escalate.
Adverse Physical Conditions
Owing to the very nature of how manmade islands are constructed, unexpected subsurface conditions are a leading cause of dispute on reclamation projects. It is when contractors begin physical construction works on the islands that unforeseen and adverse physical conditions can occur, which present significant sources of dispute on projects where reclaimed or repurposed land is involved. The question then becomes, which party has assumed the risk associated with ground conditions? Considering this point carefully at the outset of the tender and procurement stages of projects and making appropriate provision in contractual documents will provide contracting parties with some certainty as to where risk lies.
In contracts where the risk for physical conditions lies with the contractor, contractors must be aware of what employer data can be relied upon, be that geotechnical surveys, hydrological surveys or otherwise, and to what extent that data may be relied upon. Situations involving adverse physical conditions can lead to significant costs and delays on projects, exposing contractors to significant risk of having liquidated damages levied on them so it behoves contractors and developers alike to seek out legal advice at tender stage.
To minimise the risk of disputes arising from adverse physical conditions, contracting parties should carry out comprehensive due diligence at the pre-contract stage, including joint site investigations where possible. Contracts should include clear disclaimers or warranties as to the reliability of employer-provided data, and adopt well-defined clauses governing the allocation of risk for physical conditions.
Logistics and Project Execution
Another common cause for concern which requires careful project planning is logistics – how and when human and other resources can be transported to and around manmade island sites such that contractually agreed timelines are met. Once the development of a manmade island commences, i.e. post dredging and compaction, it is feasible that tens of thousands of workers will be required to build the hotels, malls and residences that ultimately generate revenue. Efficient access routes are therefore essential.
Transporting tens of thousands of workers onto sites with very limited mainland access can prove time consuming and inefficient. Interruptions to site logistics often give rise to claims for disruption and loss of productivity and is an area in which contractors will need to ensure good records are kept.
Palm Jebal Ali, a landmass 50% larger than Palm Jumeirah is slated to have three access links to mainland Dubai which, in theory, should alleviate congestion and disruption in terms of human resources and the transportation of large plant and equipment to and from the island.
To avoid logistical bottlenecks, developers should undertake comprehensive logistics planning well in advance, including simulation-based assessments of workforce movement, equipment transport, and material deliveries. Contracts should include robust site access and transport risk clauses, and contractors should maintain detailed daily records of delays or disruptions. Coordination with local authorities on access permits, offshore transport infrastructure, and customs processes for imported equipment can further reduce risk. Early investment in docking infrastructure may also bring significant long-term efficiencies.
Financial Risks
As with any significant construction or engineering project, there will be a significant financial cost and steady cashflow will be required to avoid interruption. In order to provide adequate project financing, capital is often provided by investors who invest in off-plan property sometimes even before the island itself has been constructed. A key risk for these investors is when projects are ultimately not completed which can ultimately leave investors empty handed and out of pocket. The causes of this sometimes have macro environmental origins that are unrelated to the specific construction project, such as the Global Financial Crisis of 2008/2009.
To manage financial risks, developers should diversify funding sources and avoid overreliance on off-plan sales, especially where physical completion remains distant. Where appropriate, performance guarantees, escrow arrangements, and insurance instruments cover can help protect both developers and investors from unexpected losses.
Conclusion
Manmade island developments are now a common feature in Middle Eastern construction and tourism sectors. Their growth will likely continue, albeit shaped by economic cycles, environmental scrutiny, and practical limitations, including finite coastline availability.
The nature and size of disputes that can arise from manmade island projects, be that the reclamation stage or the development stage, mean contracting parties should give serious consideration to the contractual provisions that are agreed between the parties, the laws under which those provisions will be interpreted and the dispute resolution clauses within those contracts.
Further, considering the potential challenges posed by adverse physical conditions and logistical constraints on manmade island projects, it would be prudent for contracting parties to both satisfy themselves as to site conditions as much as practicable and to carefully plan how projects can be executed and delivered.
[1] https://www.jasonmbarr.com/manhattan-extension/urban-landfill-history
[2] https://araburban.org/en/infohub/projects/?id=6717
[3] https://www.designingbuildings.co.uk/wiki/Land_reclamation
Posted by: Emma Nierinck and Marc Hoare
Return to News & Insights
