Home News & Insights International Arbitration Series – Part 5: Exploring Alternative Dispute Resolution
In this final part of our series on international construction and energy arbitration, Kevin Joyce and Alex Slade consider the alternatives to international arbitration, the advantages and disadvantages of the different methods and the factors to consider in deciding whether they are right for attempting to resolve disputes on global projects.
What is alternative dispute resolution?
Alternative dispute resolution (ADR) refers to methods outside traditional litigation or arbitration, which often offer a much more flexible, cost-effective and efficient means of resolving disputes. However, the choice of method and its effectiveness depends on the nature of the disputes, the parties involved and the jurisdiction in which the construction or energy project is located.
What are the different types of ADR?
The most common forms of ADR in international projects include:
(a) Negotiation
Negotiation is a process where the parties communicate directly with each other to try to resolve the dispute. It is the simplest and most common form of ADR and often the first step before proceeding to more formal ADR methods or, indeed, before resorting to arbitration or litigation. The key characteristics include direct dialogue between the parties, flexibility and informality and, sometimes, the involvement of a third-party to help facilitate the negotiations.
(b) Mediation
Mediation is a voluntary process in which an impartial third-party mediator helps the parties in dispute communicate and negotiate to reach a mutually agreeable solution. There are many forms of mediation, but the key characteristics usually include:
(c) Conciliation
Conciliation is similar to mediation, but the conciliator plays a more active role in proposing solutions to the dispute. The conciliator may suggest terms of settlement or propose how the dispute can be resolved. However, the solution is non-binding unless the parties agree.
(d) Expert determination
In expert determination, an independent expert with relevant knowledge of type of dispute that has arisen on the relevant construction or energy project is appointed to make a decision on the dispute.
The expert’s decision can be binding or non-binding, depending on the agreement between the parties. Typically, expert determination is used to resolve technical or factual issues, such as disputes over engineering or the quality of the works, or financial issues such as accounting or reserves issues.
(e) Dispute boards
Disputes boards, consisting of neutral experts with relevant expertise, are often established on large, international projects, particularly in the infrastructure sector, to assist the parties in resolving or avoiding disputes and with the objective of minimising the impact on delivery of the project.
There are broadly three types:
What are the advantages and disadvantages of ADR in international disputes?
The advantages and disadvantages of ADR often depend on the form chosen, but there are many common factors:
Advantages
(a) Speed
ADR is usually a far quicker process than international arbitration. This helps avoid prolonged resolution which can cause serious financial harm, business interruption and delay to delivery of the project.
(b) Cost-effectiveness
Another usual consequence of the speed of resolution is a significant reduction in legal, expert and management costs.
(c) Confidentiality
ADR processes, particularly negotiation and mediation, are typically confidential. This helps protect the reputation of the parties and the project, which is often crucial in international business relationships.
(d) Flexibility
ADR offers flexibility in terms of process and outcomes. Parties can tailor the process to meet their needs, including the venue, time and type of ADR, which can be particularly helpful in international construction and energy projects where cultural, legal and commercial differences may be significant.
(e) Preservation of relationships
Alternative forms of dispute resolution are generally more collaborative and less adversarial than international arbitration, helping the parties find mutually acceptable solutions and preserving business relationships.
(f) Control and autonomy
The parties often retain greater control over the process and the outcome, especially in methods like negotiation and mediation. This autonomy can lead to solutions that are more acceptable to both parties compared to a decision imposed on them by an arbitral tribunal.
(g) Expertise
ADR methods like expert determination and dispute boards allow the parties to appoint a neutral expert with specialised knowledge in the subject matter of the dispute. This is particularly valuable in complex international construction and energy disputes where technical expertise is required.
Disadvantages
(a) Limited scope for resolving complex legal and factual issues
ADR is often less suited for resolving disputes involving complex legal issues, particularly if formal legal precedent is required. This may be a significant disadvantage for parties looking for consistency and legal clarity in future disputes. Similarly, if decisions need to be made based on a complex set of facts, notably if witness of fact evidence is required.
(b) Enforceability
While arbitration awards are usually enforceable under international conventions (such as the New York Convention), non-binding forms of ADR such as mediation might not result in legally binding outcomes unless the parties enter into a separate settlement agreement. This can lead to uncertainty regarding enforcement, especially in international disputes where legal systems differ significantly.
(c) Risk of imbalance of power
Sometimes, one party may have more leverage than the other due to their legal standing, financial position, market dominance or access to better legal or political representation. This can make the ADR process less fair and result in an unfavourable settlement for the weaker party, especially in the less formal methods such as negotiation.
(d) Cultural and legal barriers
ADR processes in international construction and energy disputes must account for cultural differences in negotiation styles and business practices. Misunderstandings can arise if the parties are not sensitive to these differences and the lack of familiarity with the legal system in different jurisdictions can complicate the process significantly.
(e) No guaranteed outcome
While in many cases ADR is aimed at finding a mutually acceptable solution, there is no guarantee that the parties will reach a resolution – especially where the third-party cannot impose a decision, such as in mediation or conciliation. This could lead to significant delays and additional costs if the dispute is not resolved and international arbitration is necessary.
Where the ADR process results in a decision of a third party which is non-binding (such as non-binding expert determination or dispute boards), it is often the case that the dispute goes on to be adjudicated in arbitration anyway, and so extra time and costs are incurred in arguing the issues twice in different fora.
(f) Limited appeal process
In binding methods such as expert determination, there are very limited avenues for appeal. If a party is dissatisfied with the result, they may have little recourse to challenge the decision. This can be seen as a disadvantage compared to court systems that allow for multiple levels of appeal, or even compared to international arbitration where appeals are limited but the arbitral process will have provided a fuller opportunity for the party to present its case as compared to an expert determination.
Conclusion
There are many alternatives to international arbitration for resolving international construction and energy disputes, but each process has advantages and disadvantages which need to be weighed carefully in deciding whether ADR is appropriate for a particular project.
What is clear however is that ADR has become a cornerstone of dispute resolution on many high-value, technically complex global projects, such as energy plants, infrastructure projects, process facilities and data centres.
So much so, that many international contracts now incorporate ADR clauses (often based on frameworks such as FIDIC) which mandate ADR as a pre-condition to arbitration, and many international jurisdictions (such as Saudi Arabia) have established robust legal frameworks to encourage its use. This is only likely to increase with the continued internationalisation of major construction and energy projects.
Posted by: Kevin Joyce and Alexander Slade
Return to News & Insights
