Svella Connect Ltd v Virgin Media Ltd [2026] EWHC 2223 (TCC)

A TCC decision concerning fibre-network construction framework agreements provides a helpful and detailed review of the law on implied duties of good faith. The Court considered the authorities on relational contracts emphasising that the primary question remains whether orthodox implication principles justify the proposed implied term. The decision will be of interest to parties operating under long-term framework, alliance and collaborative contracting arrangements.

Background

The dispute arose from a series of NEC-based framework agreements under which Svella Connect Ltd carried out fibre network works for Virgin Media Ltd. The agreements were originally entered into with NMCN plc and later novated to Svella following NMCN’s administration. They governed the process by which individual work orders might be awarded for network expansion related construction projects.

The contracts contained an express obligation requiring the parties to act in a “spirit of mutual trust and co-operation”, but they also made clear that no guarantee was given that work would be awarded to the contractor. Virgin Media retained the ability to seek competing bids and determine which framework contractor would receive particular work orders. The agreements also contained contractual termination rights including for convenience.

Relations between the parties deteriorated and in July 2024 they entered into an Exit & Settlement Agreement, under which existing disputes were compromised, and arrangements were made for Svella’s exit from parts of the contractual relationship whilst retaining certain future opportunities under another framework agreement. The settlement included agreed work-allocation provisions, subject to specified qualifications and governance/KPI performance requirements.

The amount of work required was scaled back by Virgin Media’s customer, after which Svella issued proceedings claiming damages. Virgin Media sought summary judgment against a range of claims including fraudulent misrepresentation, intimidation, causing loss by unlawful means and breaches of alleged implied terms of good faith. By the time of the hearing, most of those claims had been abandoned by Svella leaving primarily its case that implied duties of good faith existed in both the framework agreements and the Exit & Settlement Agreement.

The issue

The Court had to determine whether Svella had a real prospect of success in establishing that the relevant contracts contained implied duties of good faith.

Svella argued that the agreements were “relational contracts” involving long-term collaboration, mutual trust, communication, co-operation with expectations of loyalty. It contended that duties should therefore be implied requiring the parties to act honestly, refrain from frustrating the contractual purpose, and avoid conduct regarded as commercially unacceptable by reasonable and honest people.

Virgin Media argued that the contracts were detailed commercial agreements which already provided for and regulated the parties’ relationship leaving no contractual “gap” requiring the implication of additional duties. Virgin Media also argued that many of the matters relied upon by Svella as being covered by such implied duties were already governed by express provisions.

The decision

Mr Justice Pepperall granted summary judgment in Virgin Media’s favour on Svella’s implied good-faith claims.

Reviewing authorities including Yam Seng, Al Nehayan, Bates v Post Office, UTB v Sheffield United and Candey Ltd v Bosheh, the Court emphasised that the starting point remains the orthodox law on implied terms. The key question was whether the contracts contained a gap requiring implication of the pleaded duties and whether those duties were necessary or obvious.

Applying those principles, the Court held that the framework agreements were detailed commercial contracts which already regulated the parties’ relationship. They contained an express obligation to act in a “spirit of mutual trust and co-operation“, expressly stated that no work was guaranteed, permitted competitive bidding and contained termination rights. The Court therefore found no contractual gap requiring the implication of the pleaded good-faith duties.

The Court reached the same conclusion in relation to the Exit & Settlement Agreement, which it regarded as a carefully negotiated settlement governing the parties’ separation and containing its own express mechanisms.

The Court also declined to permit the new pleaded allegations of breach of good faith, finding that many either duplicated express contractual claims or concerned matters already regulated by detailed contractual mechanisms.

One of the more notable aspects of the judgment is the Court’s treatment of the concept of a “relational contract”.

Since Yam Seng and subsequent cases, parties have frequently focused on whether a contract can be characterised as relational when arguing that a duty of good faith should be implied. Mr Justice Pepperall accepted that the concept remains relevant, but emphasised that it should not displace the orthodox law relating to the implication of contractual terms. In particular, he stated that the “critical enquiry” is whether the parties’ agreement has been fully set out in the contract and, if not, whether the proposed term satisfies the conventional tests for implication. The Court described the factors identified in Bates v Post Office as a useful “sense check” rather than an alternative legal test.

The judgment therefore builds on more recent authorities such as UTB and Candey, which caution against treating the existence of a relational contract as sufficient, by itself, to justify the implication of a duty of good faith. Instead, the Court emphasised that necessity remains the touchstone and that implied terms are not available to rewrite or supplement a detailed bargain simply because a broader obligation would appear commercially attractive.

Practical implications for the industry

The judgment is likely to be of interest to employers, contractors and in-house legal teams involved in long-term framework and alliance-style arrangements.

As always, much will depend on the specific wording of the contract and the implied term that is said to arise, but the following points stand out.

First, describing a contract as “relational” may no longer carry the weight sometimes attributed to that label. The judgment suggests that parties will still need to identify a specific contractual gap and explain why implication of the proposed term is necessary or obvious. Relational characteristics may inform that exercise but do not replace it.

Second, detailed drafting remains the strongest protection against implied obligations. The Court repeatedly stressed that the agreements already addressed work allocation, co-operation, performance monitoring, audits, improvement plans, suspension rights and termination. That detailed contractual machinery was a central basis for refusing to imply further duties.

Third, express co-operation provisions may reduce the scope for broader implied duties. The framework agreements already required the parties to act in a “spirit of mutual trust and co-operation“. The Court treated that as evidence that the parties had consciously regulated the relevant subject matter themselves.

Fourth, settlement agreements may face difficulties where good-faith duties are said to arise by implication. The Court regarded an implied duty of good faith in the Exit & Settlement Agreement as less tenable than the frameworks noting it was a carefully negotiated transaction intended to regulate the parties’ separation containing express provisions dealing with future work allocation.

Gurbinder Grewal, Alice Andreoletti and Oliver Pickford acted for Virgin Media instructing Sanjay Patel KC and Daniel Churcher of 4 Pump Court.

This article is intended as general commentary only and does not constitute legal advice.

Loading