Home News & Insights Energy Disputes Series – Introduction
Current Challenges in the Energy Sector
The energy sector is the driver of modern life and is rarely out of the national and international news. The International Energy Agency’s Global Energy Review 2025 showed record global energy consumption in 2024, with demand growing at a faster rate (2.2%) than the average rate over the previous decade. This included a return to growth in consumption in advanced economies.[1] The growth in energy consumption was driven by increased fossil fuel consumption (even after 2023’s record highs), and even greater increases in renewable and alternative electricity generation.
The global economy was already in a period of significant uncertainty, and the second Trump administration in the US has potentially added further to that uncertainty. The recent strikes on Iran by Israel and the US have caused unsurprising spikes in crude oil prices, and the Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2022 showed the impact of global conflicts on energy prices. Tariff wars and shifting geopolitical relations, especially with the US, add to these conflicts and the challenges of climate change, energy poverty, and security. These factors have made the energy sector’s future more unpredictable than ever. Given its reliance on long-term, capital-intensive partnerships and global, cross-border infrastructure projects, the sector is especially vulnerable to these global issues. Global market fragility has made long-term planning and risk allocation in the sector more difficult, as stakeholders grapple with whether traditional contractual pricing models, such as take-or-pay arrangements or fixed-price PPAs, remain fit for purpose in a world of unpredictable shocks and frequent geopolitical shifts.
As a result, the energy sector has consistently been a significant source of international disputes. For instance, in 2023[2] energy disputes amounted to: 20.6% of ICC arbitrations;[3] 14% of LCIA arbitrations (though transport & commodities disputes, a number of which will be energy-related, are counted separately by the LCIA and constituted 36% of cases);[4] and 35% of ICSID arbitrations.[5] This data only shows part of the picture of energy-related disputes globally, as many disagreements related to energy projects may be captured by other descriptions in the data, and some will be resolved by expert determination or Disputes Boards without making it to a full arbitration.
There are therefore a number of challenges facing the energy sector that are likely to result in disputes in the future. Some of these are consistent risks that the sector has always faced: changes in government policy and regulation, for example, are always going to occur in the energy sector. The question is the extent to which energy sector participants’ rights are affected by such changes. In addition to these enduring challenges, new issues arise regularly that can affect the viability of existing contracts or call into question the feasibility of new and existing projects. This partly reflects the rapidly changing nature of the energy industry, and its remarkable adoption of new technology. The pace of technological change is having a direct impact on current and historical projects, rendering some close to obsolete long before their expected operational lifespan ends.
In 2025, some of the additional challenges include: a shift in political emphasis back towards traditional oil and gas, as compared to recent focus on renewable electricity generation; continuing (and increasing) geopolitical tensions and armed conflicts causing significant uncertainty over projects, which shift priorities for both governments and market participants, increase energy security risks, and contribute to price variability; some countries’ growing isolationism and protectionism in global affairs; resource nationalism, which impacts both energy projects and mining for the critical minerals necessary for the energy transition; supply chain difficulties, particularly for large scale infrastructure projects; and the development, at pace, of new technologies. These challenges do not only affect project viability, they also impact contract interpretation and execution. Parties are now frequently litigating the interpretation of force majeure, limitation, hardship and stabilisation clauses. This is especially true in legal systems of host countries where precedent is limited or non-binding, leaving tribunals to balance policy concerns against legal tests and contract terms.
Pricing and Contract Disputes on the Rise
Alongside these are challenges stemming from pricing issues. In the oil and gas sector, changes in the oil price (and, more recently, in gas pricing as it has become decoupled from the oil price) have always influenced the types and frequency of disputes. Increased geopolitical tensions and conflicts inevitably lead to oil and gas price volatility. As renewable projects have grown, pricing has also been a key issue. The large number of investment treaty claims against various countries relating to subsidies and incentives for solar generation shows this clearly, and in recent years we have seen pricing structures for renewables projects emerge as key drivers of project viability (and therefore disputes) – see, for example, the cancellation or delay of offshore wind projects in the UK and Europe as a result of cost increases making the underlying project uneconomic.[6] Price disputes are also arising from decarbonisation-linked contractual obligations for instance: disagreements over cost allocation for emissions-reduction technologies in shared infrastructure, or over carbon intensity penalties in LNG SPAs. These newer forms of risk are reshaping how pricing clauses are drafted and challenged.
Introducing Our Energy Disputes Series
The resolution of disputes in the energy sector is one of Mantle Law’s core practice areas. We focus on helping clients to navigate differences and avoid disputes, where possible, across the whole sector, from oil, gas, and mining, to renewables, nuclear, and energy infrastructure construction projects.
So, what does the landscape of energy disputes look like? What different factors do we see arising in the variety of energy disputes we encounter?
To share our perspective on these questions and related topics, we are launching a series of articles focused on disputes in the energy sector. While we can’t predict the future, we hope to spark discussion and reflection on the range of disputes emerging across the sector.
The topics will vary, just like the sector itself, and will no doubt evolve over time. We will start with an article next week on disputes in the offshore wind sector. We hope you enjoy reading and welcome any thoughts.
[1] https://www.iea.org/reports/global-energy-review-2025/key-findings
[2] At the time of writing, the latest year for which all the following institutions have published full statistics
[3] 2023 ICC Dispute Resolution Statistics
[4] 2023 LCIA Annual Casework Report
[5] ICSID Caseload Statistics Issue 2024-1, notably this rose to 62% in 2024
[6] https://mantlelaw.com/offshore-wind-recent-developments-and-supply-chain-challenges/
Posted by: Alexander Slade
Return to News & Insights
