Managing Offshore Disputes

Introduction

The renewable energy sector is experiencing rapid growth, driven by the urgent need globally to address climate change and achieve net zero commitments. However, this burgeoning market is not without its challenges. As new technologies, such as offshore floating wind platforms, emerge, they bring with them a host of potential disputes and risks in addition to their efficiencies and innovations.

The offshore wind industry faces a number of challenges that are unique to it as an emerging market set against a challenging operational offshore backdrop. We explore a number of these in this article, how they can impact the potential for disputes, and what parties can do to best mitigate their risk.

What are the potential issues facing the offshore wind industry?

Gaps in contractual interpretation

Industry participants are adapting standard forms, such as FIDIC, for use in offshore wind projects. However, arguably, the FIDIC suite of contracts does not include sufficient flexibility for use in offshore projects, and often needs to be adapted to include provision for industry specific issues, such as adverse weather conditions (for example, particular weather windows in the North Sea) and the role of the marine warranty surveyor. There are also transport logistics, in terms of construction, that may be more complex than a standard form contract adequately provides for. As such, standard forms often require a significant amount of project-specific amendment. This adaptation can lead to ambiguities and gaps in contractual coverage that can leave parties exposed to unanticipated risk or uncertainty around interpretation, and therefore a heightened likelihood of disputes.

Cost Volatility

Parties implementing new technologies on projects are often at risk of uncertain and unpredictable/unforeseeable costs arising. This potential cost volatility can serve as a bar to entry for developers and contractors seeking to diversify their offerings into new and developing technology.

In the offshore wind sector, a wide array of specialist equipment is required across the project lifecycle, from development and construction to operations and decommissioning. This includes specialised foundation installation, specialised offshore wind turbine components, floating platforms, subsea cabling, and installation support vessels, and the more specialist the requirement, then typically higher the cost. As a result, offshore wind projects are particularly susceptible to cost volatility, which can change the commercial position of both the employer and the contractor, leading to disputes as both parties try to protect the economics of the project.

Vessels

The installation of an offshore wind platform requires a significant number of usually specialist vessels to support installation. Various vessels are required, such as heavy-lift vessels, cable lay vessels, scour protection installation vessels and floating crane vessels, and the newer generation of specialised turbine installation vessels, as well as the more traditional ‘marine spread’ vessels required on any offshore project.

Depending on the size and capacity of the contractor, the relevant vessels may be owned by the contractor and internally ‘subcontracted’ for projects, or the main contractor may subcontract the vessel supply from various other suppliers. But what happens when adverse weather means the project suffers idle time, and equipment that had been made available for the project has to move on to another? Who bears the weather risk, and is this the same throughout the vessel supply chain?

Allocating risk for the unavailability of vessels is far from straightforward. Where specialist vessels are concerned, there are only a small number of contractors who own and operate them, and execution methodologies and temporary works (such as rigging) for each project have to be designed specifically to suit the particular vessel that will be used. A change in the vessel will often necessitate a completely different design and execution methodology, which can also mean different requirements for underlying data (for example, the information on ground conditions required to plan the installation of fixed-bottom foundations by a jack-up vessel is very different from the information required if the installation vessel uses dynamic positioning and does not jack-up from the seabed).

Where a vessel becomes unavailable for whatever legitimate reason, from a contractor’s perspective, there is likely to be a need for a mechanism for relief from time and costs. Equally, an employer/developer does not want to be exposed to delays and extra costs because of vessel availability, particularly as such delays may have an impact up the line on other project works packages and milestones. So it is important for mechanisms to be built into contracts to anticipate this, otherwise there is a significantly increased risk of disputes arising.

Weather Risk

In addition to vessel unavailability, the offshore environment itself brings physical challenges in terms of weather and ocean behaviour. These challenges are not new – the oil and gas industry has been dealing with them for decades – but climate change has made that environment more volatile, and the nature of offshore windfarms (with many tens of turbine locations in very close proximity) means that projects are often more complex and more exposed to increased delays and disruptions from weather related issues.

During the construction phase, the complexity of these projects, and the number of specialist contractors likely involved, means that adverse weather may have a particularly acute risk on the supply chain, leading to lengthy and unforeseen consequential delays. This is particularly true where offshore works are constrained by limited weather windows or vessel availability, and where delays in one package – such as foundation installation or cable laying – can have cascading effects on the scheduling of turbine erection, commissioning and grid connection. These interdependencies may give rise to claims for extensions of time, disruption costs, or liquidated damages, especially where interface risk allocation has not been clearly defined in the underlying contracts.

Post-completion, during operation, weather risks persist. The more volatile the weather environment for projects, as is the case offshore, the higher the risk that potential additional costs will be incurred for downtime, breakages and maintenance.

Developing standards

Another inherent problem with new or developing technology is that unproven technology and systems are difficult to benchmark. It becomes particularly challenging for parties to understand, negotiate and apply key contractual concepts such as ‘fitness for purpose’ when technology is relatively untested and lacks an established performance baseline.

Again, this is not a new problem – anyone working with innovative technologies or state-of-the-art design will be familiar with the uncertainty this introduces. But where the technology is both novel and significant in scale and value, as is often the case in offshore wind, it becomes even more critical to establish what standard of performance will apply.

Parties should give careful thought to how risk is allocated in relation to technological performance, including whether warranties are absolute or subject to carve-outs for reasonable skill and care, and how disputes over defects or underperformance will be assessed in the absence of widely accepted industry norms. This leads to further critical considerations: what is the appropriate benchmark for assessing reasonable skill and care in the context of novel technology? Where do those standards sit in the suite of contracts: are they clearly incorporated into the operative clauses, referenced in the Employer’s Requirements, or do they sit in appendices or secondary documents?

When dealing with new or evolving technologies, a fundamental question is therefore whether there are already relevant and applicable technical standards that could apply to performance. Has the employer expressly required compliance with specific, recognised standards, or is the contractor instead expected to apply analogous benchmarks from other industries or jurisdictions? Even where standards are identified, are they practically achievable at the scale or in the offshore environment of the project? Have they been tested, validated, or simply assumed?

The contractual risk allocation on these issues become critical when disputes arise and these questions about performance standards are therefore key to an offshore wind project’s risk and liability allocation. Addressing them clearly in the contract, through express obligations, tested specifications and workable performance requirements, and a careful approach to accounting for these issues can help to avoid, or mitigate the impact of, disputes later during project execution.

What can parties do?

In order to mitigate these risks as much as possible, it is important to start at the beginning of a project, with a clear assessment of the technology and operational environment. Contractual obligations should be aligned with what is realistically achievable, and technical standards must be carefully chosen, defined, and embedded within the contract.

In this regard, the form of the contract will be important. While there are risks involved in amending a standard form or writing one from scratch, a bespoke contract may nonetheless be the best approach if the risk allocation needs to be considered in a way that is not aligned with the risk allocation as drafted under any one standard form.

Once the form is decided, parties should consider how to manage the allocation of risk in respect of the issues raised in this article, and extending to other issues such as site conditions and access. Express provision for these issues in the contract may help to avoid or lessen the impact of disputes during project execution, particularly if a balanced approach can be found to risk allocation. Consideration should also be given to the supply chain, and the extent to which the various contractual commitments up and down the chain are dependent upon timely vessel access.

As noted above, a key challenge offshore is adverse weather. It may be most appropriate to have specific provisions addressing a balanced approach to risk allocation for adverse weather. Other options, such as attempting to rely on force majeure clauses, are less certain and create a greater risk of disputes. In this respect it is important to be mindful of the local law provisions of the contract’s governing law; for example, if the contract is governed by English law, force majeure provisions are a creature of the contract and provide relief only to the extent stated in the contractual provision.

For nascent technology, the inclusion of performance degradation benchmarks, technology refresh clauses and provisions allowing for the development or innovation of technology should be considered. This should include consideration of how provisions are made for changes to the financial aspects of the project, in the event that advances in technology lead to significant changes in project economics.

Similarly, considering progressive risk allocation and reassessment of milestones within a framework agreement or risk allocation schedule may permit the parties to mitigate effects of unforeseen issues as well as to avoid disputes.

For example, a risk allocation schedule may identify particular risks (such as ground conditions, weather conditions, supply chain risks and regulatory risks), assess the level of risk, and then set a threshold level over which the risk is allocated differently. Taking weather conditions as an example, it could provide that if weather worse than the threshold limits is suffered for a particular duration, or affects particular activities, the contractor is entitled to an extension of time, with or without costs.

Conclusion

Pressure to achieve net zero obligations has brought about the rapid development of offshore wind projects. However, lags in the contractual matrix, compounded by the industry’s unique challenges, can leave parties exposed to risks and potential disputes during all phases of project execution.

Careful consideration of the potential risks and addressing these at the earliest point of the project is obvious advice, but will not always prove possible. Where realistic, capturing the inherent risks of the projects within the risk allocation structure of the contract is certainly the best route to balancing the positions of the contractual counterparties with the desire to complete the project as quickly and as efficiently as possible.

There have been welcome moves towards attempting to create greater certainty and uniformity across the industry, such as the International Marine Contractor’s Association’s risk allocation principles which were released in January 2023, and FIDIC Task Force 14 which has been seeking to produce a standard form contract for the offshore wind sector.

We would anticipate that this positive industry trend will continue, and hope to see the development of risk allocation framework and standard forms for offshore wind progress over the coming years – but in the meantime, parties should proceed with caution and ensure that their interests are robustly protected.

Note

Mantle Law has significant experience advising on offshore wind projects in various jurisdictions and so please contact us with any further queries.

Posted by: Alexander Slade and

Return to News & Insights
Loading