Home News & Insights Dispute Boards: A DAB-hand at dispute resolution?
The Centre of Construction Law & Dispute Resolution at King’s College London has recently published a report on the worldwide use of dispute boards over the past six years, and it makes for interesting reading.
Here are 5 key takeaways from the report, which are relevant to anyone involved in construction, infrastructure or energy projects in the UK or internationally, who is thinking about using dispute boards as a mechanism for managing disputes on their projects, or is already party to contracts which provide for them.
There is no single definition of the term “dispute board”, which encompasses a wide variety of contractual dispute resolution procedure. Commonly encountered terms include “dispute adjudication boards”, “dispute avoidance boards”, “dispute review boards”, “dispute advisory boards”, which belie significant differences in how dispute boards may be set up. Some of the key variables include:
The report highlights that the constitution of dispute boards tends to be heavily driven by the use of standard forms of contract which contain the dispute board provisions. With most of the standard forms now featuring dispute board terms including FIDIC, NEC and JCT, it is increasingly important for parties to ‘look behind the headlines’ and consider whether a dispute board is right for their projects, and in particular, what sort, and tailor the provisions accordingly.
One message that emerges clearly is that submission of disputes to the dispute board is invariably stated to be a mandatory pre-condition to starting subsequent dispute resolution procedures. This is indeed the approach adopted by most of the standard forms. However, parties should consider carefully whether this is, in fact, what they want, as this can often be a time-consuming and costly barrier to pursuing a final determination of a dispute, if for whatever reason a party concludes that is what is ultimately required.
On the whole, the report paints a positive picture on the effectiveness of dispute boards as a dispute avoidance/resolution mechanism. Nearly two-thirds of individual respondents (66%) reported that parties complied with non-binding recommendations of dispute boards “always” or “most of the time”. In the case of binding decisions, such as FIDIC, the figure was 70%. This data indicates that dispute boards, where they are used, in many cases act as a de facto ‘final’ dispute resolution procedure, regardless of whether their findings are stated to be binding or not.
The research conducted by King’s has also sought to gather data on whether dispute boards are effective at avoiding disputes in the first place. The data here appears to be more mixed, with significant variability as to whether dispute avoidance measures are being regularly adopted by dispute boards and their effectiveness. This may be because many clients do not opt for a standing dispute board on the basis of cost. However, interestingly, a third of respondents reported that, where dispute avoidance measures were adopted, the scope of the dispute was significantly reduced, and 45% of individual respondents said the dispute was completely avoided altogether.
A common barrier to the effectiveness of dispute boards as a dispute resolution tool has traditionally been that decisions are difficult to enforce if parties refuse to comply with them. Encouragingly, as noted above, in the vast majority of cases enforcement is unnecessary as the parties voluntarily comply. However, where parties refuse to comply with a dispute board decision or recommendation, enforcement is likely to remain a challenge. The report notes there is still very little empirical data on the enforcement of dispute board decisions. Where enforcement action has been taken, the most common method reported involved some form of arbitration proceedings, either via an interim arbitral award (36%), a final award (18%) or an interim measure (13%), although 55% of relevant respondents also reported being involved in court enforcement proceedings. The Persero case in Singapore confirmed the temporarily binding nature of a DAB decision under the 1999 FIDIC Red Book and that this could be enforced by way of interim award without any requirement to refer the secondary dispute (i.e., non-compliance) back to the DAB or submit the underlying dispute to arbitration. However, the report does not include data on the time and cost associated with such enforcement proceedings, which are likely to be substantial. Thus, there is still a risk there are no cost-effective means to enforce a dispute board’s decision if the other side refuses to comply. Here, the report notes the majority of respondents agree that the construction industry would benefit from an international convention facilitating circulation and enforcement of dispute board decisions. An international regime akin to legislative measures adopted to support enforcement of adjudicator’s decisions in the UK, for example, could be welcome.
There is an old adage that a “stitch in time saves nine”, meaning that if you sort out a problem immediately it may save a lot of extra work, and cost, later on. The same may well be true of dispute boards. Dispute boards, particularly standing ones, can require a degree of ‘up-front’ investment, which may be the last thing parties want in an industry where margins are notoriously tight. The report notes that costs are a concern to users and may lead to the decision (often taken by project teams looking to save money rather than those with an eye on dispute resolution) not to adopt a dispute board in the contract. However, the report finds that in the vast majority of cases the average annual retainer fee is less than US$50,000 per annum. While this may seem like an unwanted additional cost at the beginning of a project when the going is good, such costs would be dwarfed by the costs associated with arbitration or litigation if things go wrong, and can be shared by the parties if they are able to recognise the potential mutual benefits at the outset.
Perhaps the most illuminating part of the report is the respondents’ additional free-text comments in chapter 14. These confirm that when it comes to the effectiveness of dispute boards as a dispute management tool, the devil really is in the detail. This includes the importance of things like:
As one respondent notes, “The references to DABs that I have been involved with all become close to arbitration procedures, with the involvement of both senior (KC) and junior barristers, planning & quantum experts and the application of formal legal procedures found in litigation.”
Clearly, it does not make sense for dispute boards to seek to replicate final dispute resolution procedures. But used properly, as the report highlights, they can be a very effective tool to help parties manage disputes on project when they arise, which can avoid more costly arbitration or litigation down the track.
At Mantle Law we have extensive experience of advising parties on dispute board provisions and acting on behalf of parties through DAB proceedings in jurisdictions around the world. If you would like to speak to a member of the team further about the use of dispute boards on international construction, infrastructure and energy projects, please get in touch.
Posted by: Lucy Walton and James Pratt
Return to News & Insights
