Flash briefing: Supreme Court hands down judgment in landmark URS v BDW decision

The UK Supreme Court has today handed down its highly-anticipated judgment in the landmark case of URS Corporation Ltd v BDW Trading Ltd [2025] UKSC 21.

The appeal was heard by a full panel of 7 justices who unanimously dismissed URS’s appeal on all 4 grounds.

There is much to digest in the judgment that runs to 89 pages, but it is clearly one that will have far-reaching implications for developers, contractors, consultants and insurers alike.

Here are the key headlines:

  1. Liability for pure economic losses voluntarily incurred

That URS, as a professional consultant, in principle owed a duty of care in tort towards BDW to avoid pure economic loss was uncontroversial.  The question before the court was whether that duty extended to a loss that had been ‘voluntarily’ incurred by BDW.  The Supreme Court was clear in deciding that there was no “voluntariness principle” which deemed that repair costs, voluntarily assumed, fall outside the scope of the normal professional consultant’s duty to avoid pure economic loss (although this may be relevant to legal causation and mitigation).  In any event, the Supreme Court said that any repairs were not ‘voluntary’ as they were necessary to secure the safety of the residents.

  1. Extended limitation period introduced by the BSA 2022 has retrospective effect

Unsurprisingly, the Supreme Court had no difficulty in finding that section 135 of the Building Safety Act 2022, which established a 30-year limitation period for claims relating to historic building work under the DPA, has retrospective effect, regardless of whether proceedings are already in train.

More interestingly, the Supreme Court  confirmed that section 135 also extended the limitation period for claims “which are dependent on the limitation period in section 1 of the DPA but are not actions brought under that section”, including claims in negligence and claims in contribution.  The scope of this apparent extension is likely to be the subject of much debate in due course.

  1. Developers are owed a duty of care under the DPA

The Supreme Court confirmed that developers can both owe and be owed a duty under section 1 of the DPA.  The duty under section 1 is owed to any person, including a developer, to whose “order” a dwelling is being built.  In this case, relevant work was carried out by URS “to the order of” BDW and URS therefore owed a section 1 DPA duty to BDW.  This judgment continues to underline the potential scope of the hitherto neglected remedy for defective building work under section 1 DPA, which has been reinvigorated by the introduction of the BSA 2022.

  1. Contribution claims are available to a party who has voluntarily assumed a liability for repairs, regardless of whether there is a third party claim

There is no requirement for a judgment or settlement between a claimant and a third party, or for any claim to have been asserted by a third party, in order for a claim in contribution to arise.  The Supreme Court concluded it was sufficient that BDW had made a “payment in kind” (by performing remedial works) in compensation for the damage suffered by the homeowners.

  1. Pirelli survives, for now

The Supreme Court declined to overrule Pirelli, as it was suspected they might, in relation to the question of when a cause of action in negligence accrues.  Thus, the orthodox principle that the cause of action in negligence accrues when the relevant “damage” occurs survives.  However, the court went on to say, obiter, that, in the context of pure economic loss, “there are strong arguments of principle for accepting that there can only be an actual loss once the pure economic loss has been discovered or could reasonably have been discovered”, and that moving the law to a ‘date of discoverability’ test in the context of defective buildings “raises difficult issues”.  Thus, it seems the door has been left ajar for this issue to be revisited in the right case in the future.

Commentary

Despite these issues going all the way to the Supreme Court, it is important to remember they are still just preliminary issues.

There has yet to be a full trial of BDW’s claims against URS addressing liability, causation and quantum, and the Supreme Court was at pains to make clear that, while URS’s arguments as to ‘voluntariness’ did not impact the scope of URS’ duty of care, they may still be relevant to “legal causation and mitigation”.

Thus, while there will quite rightly be much debate and analysis of the Supreme Court’s judgment today, it’s also important to keep it in perspective.  There is still a long way for this litigation to go yet.

That said, if the industry was hoping for some rowing back of the more general trend towards imposing liability on those responsible for delivering defective and unsafe buildings post-Grenfell and the BSA, the Supreme Court did not deliver that today.

A more detailed briefing will follow in the coming days.

A copy of the judgment case be accessed here: https://supremecourt.uk/uploads/uksc_2023_0110_judgment_225bb619df.pdf

Posted by: James Pratt and

Return to News & Insights
Loading