With tariffs and protectionist economic policies dominating global headlines – particularly those now being advanced by the United States on, at least for a time, seemingly all global trading partners – effective contracting has once again become a front-line risk management tool. For in-house lawyers working across complex, cross-border supply chains or overseeing major global projects, it is an opportune time to reconsider and bolster standard terms.

The potential disruptions from the growing unpredictability of global markets and policy are vast, and have led to rising material and logistics costs, trade measures and retaliatory trade measures, and changes in government policy that impact project delivery. Against this backdrop it is critical to revisit and consider contractual provisions to ensure that these are able to withstand (and where possible protect against) disruption.

Whilst not an exhaustive list, below are five key provisions to review and tactically consider. Usually considered ‘boilerplate’ provisions, these contractual mechanisms can be strategically drafted in order to offer protection in an uncertain economic and political climate.

  1. Price Adjustment and Cost Escalation Clauses

Tariffs have the potential to distort the economic assumptions underpinning contracts, and therefore to affect profitability (or even in some instances the economic viability of the transaction). This risk is heightened if a project has a multi-layered global supply chain, or if a transaction is heavily reliant on imports or ‘just in time’ logistics.

In order to safeguard against the negative impact of tariffs or unexpected economic measures on project profitability, contracts should allow for price adjustment mechanisms or cost escalation clauses that are in turn tied to:

  • Objective indices (e.g. global steel prices, a consumer price index, or freight indexes like the Baltic Dry Index)
  • Specific government-imposed tariffs or trade restrictions
  • Material price swings beyond an agreed and defined threshold

In long-term contracts, cost escalation clauses can be used to apportion risk of rising input costs between the parties, either through shared thresholds or tiered adjustment mechanisms. Price adjustment mechanisms, offering broader relief, can also allow for adjustments to scope, exchange rate fluctuations or productivity benchmarks.  Further, in the current economic climate, parties should carefully consider whether a fixed-price structure may be worth the risk, or if a more nuanced, flexible approach will better preserve project viability and protect against volatility.

  1. Force Majeure

While some tariffs might be foreseeable in today’s climate, sudden or retroactive impositions may constitute force majeure dependent upon the drafting of the specific clause.

Force majeure clauses should consider including the following:

  • “Governmental acts or omissions”
  • “Export controls,” “tariff barriers,” “trade sanctions,” and “regulatory action”
  • “Acts of foreign states”, not only contracting parties’ and project’s home governments

However, beware of broadening the clause too far. In most cases, the relief afforded is available to both parties. So, if a counterparty is more likely to be affected by such disruptions, a narrowly tailored clause may offer better control.

Equally important, force majeure procedural steps should not be overlooked at the drafting stage. It should be ensured that contracts:

  • Require prompt notice of force majeure
  • Specify mitigation obligations
  • Limit relief to the duration of the disruption, and
  • Allow termination after a defined period of prolonged force majeure

Parties should ensure that their contract makes provision for what they may require (or conversely, ensure that the provisions are not overly generous to their counterparty). For example, notably the FIDIC suite of contracts often provide for extension of time relief for incidents of force majeure, but importantly not for additional costs that arise out of that force majeure. It should be considered in each circumstance whether this will provide adequate provision.

  1. Change in Law Provisions

Tariffs are often introduced by executive order, not by statute; they are also usually the acts of a government foreign to the contractual parties and project location. However, a well-drafted change in law clause can offer a valuable basis for renegotiation.

A well-drafted clause should:

  • Cover laws, regulations, and governmental orders
  • Include changes in interpretation or enforcement
  • Include government actions, defined broadly, by any relevant state, not just the contracting parties’ and project’s home jurisdictions and
  • Allow for adjustments not just to price, but also to timeline and scope

These provisions are particularly important in long-term contracts or in sectors where there are likely to be multiple jurisdictions at play.

  1. Termination and Suspension Rights

In periods of volatility, flexibility in terms of project progress and duration is critical, and can be extremely valuable. Including clear suspension and termination rights may provide some ‘breathing space’ in the event that market conditions deteriorate or performance under the contract is rendered uneconomic (or unlawful).

A party should consider:

  • A right to suspend performance if input costs rise above a defined threshold, or if a tariff makes further supply impossible or unlawful
  • A termination for convenience clause, ideally with a capped break fee or cost recovery mechanism
  • Linking these rights to specific external triggers (e.g. a defined tariff level or embargo), rather than vague notions of hardship
  • Analysing a counterparty’s exit rights. Are they reciprocal? Are they too broad/can they be exploited?
  • Ensuring that every scenario is included; it is not likely that suspension or termination rights will be inferred if they are not expressly stated, whatever the governing law
  1. Dispute Resolution and Governing Law

When tensions are high, disputes are not unlikely. In this regard, consideration of enforceability at the contracting stage is key. Being able to enforce any judgment or award in a neutral, enforcement-friendly jurisdiction will be of the utmost importance in the event of a dispute.

Some key considerations are as follows:

  • International arbitration, seated in a jurisdiction where the local courts have a proven track record of supporting and facilitating arbitration, can be a strong choice as regards enforcement.
  • If possible, use well-recognised and tested rules of arbitration (e.g., ICC, LCIA, SIAC) and specify the institution, not only the rules. Ensure that the drafting is clear – is the institution correctly named? If the rules are named, does the drafting allow for new versions/updates?
  • If local courts are preferable as a forum, consider together with locally qualified counsel how enforcement will be dealt with.
  • Choose a governing law with a track record of commercial predictability. Some jurisdictions may adopt more interventionist approaches in times of trade conflict, particularly if state-owned entities are involved. If the law chosen is not familiar to you, discuss with local counsel how it is likely to apply to the contract (e.g. does it take a ‘black letter’ approach to interpretation?), and bear this in mind for drafting.

Conclusion: Drafting can be both a shield and sword

In times of trouble, words matter; a well drafted contract will be able to offer some certainty and protection. Whether the threat comes from tariffs, sanctions or political retaliatory measures, by closely considering the drafting, in-house counsel can proactively seek to shelter their companies from the worst effects of the present economic and political climate.

 


 

Contact Emma Nierinck for more information.

Loading