Construction projects are inherently high-risk undertakings and the use of clear and precise terms in allocating these risks is essential to a project’s success.

Standard form contracts (such as the JCT, NEC4 and FIDIC) remain the default framework for the vast majority of construction projects but are often amended to reflect the unique risks, commercial dynamics and technical requirements of a specific project.

While these amendments are often the subject of extensive negotiation, the typically tight timescales for commencement of the works on site mean they are frequently accompanied by a number of commercial documents, including:

  1. Clarifications – intended to further explain or define certain terms in contracts, such as the meaning of “quality standards” or to allocate responsibility for certain activities
  2. Qualifications – intended to modify or limit certain aspects of the contract, typically to exclude certain obligations, reduce liability or narrow the scope of work
  3. Assumptions – intended to specify pre-conditions for performance of the work and said to provide a foundation for renegotiation or adjustment of the price or programme if those assumptions are later found to be incorrect

But while the use of these documents is often commercially convenient, their use can create substantial legal risk and uncertainty unless managed carefully – as vividly illustrated by the recent cases of Workman Properties Ltd v ADI Building & Refurbishment Ltd and Sisk v Capital & Centric Ltd.

Workman Properties Ltd v ADI Building & Refurbishment Ltd (2024)

This case revolved around whether ADI (the Contractor) or Workman Properties (the Employer) was responsible for completing the design to RIBA Stage 4 under an amended JCT Design & Build Contract 2016.

The Contractor argued that it was entitled to rely on a document that the Employer had provided during the tender process, and which was incorporated into the Employer’s Requirements, which indicated (or, as the Contractor claimed, warranted) that the Employer had completed the design up to Stage 4 – thus limiting the Contractor’s design responsibility to Stage 4 onwards.

The court took a strict view of the contractual documents and found no such warranty existed. The court concluded that the “clarification” was not sufficiently incorporated into the contract to override or alter the express terms of the contract – which clearly allocated responsibility for the entire design onto the Contractor.

The court emphasised that unless a “clarification” or tender query response is clearly and expressly included in the formal contract documents, it cannot displace the preponderance of the express terms of the contract.

Sisk v Capital & Centric Ltd (2025)

In this case, the issue was even more stark. The dispute concerned which party bore the risks associated with the condition of the existing structures on site.

The bespoke amendments to the JCT Design & Build Contract 2016 stated that the Contractor was responsible for all risks in relation to the site, including risks associated with the existing structures, subject to certain “Clarifications”.

The Contractor considered that the “Contract Clarifications”, included within the Employer’s Requirements and prepared during negotiations, had shifted this risk back to the Employer.

The Employer considered that the “Tender Clarifications”, which were included only within the electronic copy of the contract and not the hard copy, made clear that the Contractor retained responsibility for the existing structures.

The court held that only the “Contract Clarifications” were binding. The separate “Tender Clarifications” had not been effectively incorporated and could not be used to amend the risk allocation in the executed contract.

How to manage the risk of ‘commercial amendments’

To avoid the pitfalls highlighted by these cases, parties should:

  • Clearly list and formally incorporate any commercial terms into the contract
  • Use a formal schedule of amendments to vary the terms of the contract
  • Ensure that any clarifications, qualifications or assumptions do not conflict with the terms of the contract
  • Amend entire agreement clauses to specifically carve out incorporated clarifications, qualifications and assumptions
  • Include a hierarchy of documents to resolve any inconsistencies
  • Carefully manage pre-contractual correspondence to avoid unintended reliance on non-binding documents
  • Carry out a full legal and integration review before execution of the contract, to verify that all intended terms are either reflected in the contract or formally incorporated

Conclusions

Workman and Sisk highlight a recurring danger in the construction sector: the informal or inconsistent use of ‘commercial amendments’ to revise, interpret, or supplement contractual obligations.

While clarifications, qualifications and assumptions can serve a useful role during the tender and negotiation stages of a project, their legal effect depends entirely on how – and whether – they are incorporated into the contract.

In a legal environment that prioritises precision and consistency, the use of alternative or additional approaches is almost always more effective in protecting commercial expectations and contractual rights.

Posted by: Kevin Joyce

Return to News & Insights
Loading