The Middle East is experiencing rapid urbanisation, population growth and an increase in industrial activities.

While this comes with many benefits for the region, one of the drawbacks is a higher rate of waste generation. Effective waste management is crucial for many reasons, not least because of the negative environmental impacts of the use of landfill sites. In particular, if organic waste is left to break down in landfills, it produces methane, a powerful greenhouse gas. Unless the landfill traps and burns this gas, it enters the atmosphere, contributing to climate change. Further, as waste held in landfills breaks down, pollutants can seep into the ground. These pollutant liquids, called leachate, can pollute nearby water sources, having a wider environmental impact on the region.

For these reasons, improving waste management is a pressing issue in the Middle East. This is even more so as many countries across the region have set ambitious targets to achieve ‘net zero’ and tackle climate change.

Whilst recycling is the ‘gold standard’ in terms of reducing waste, not all waste types are recyclable. So, the waste-to-energy (“WtE”) sector plays an important part in the region’s waste management profile.

WtE – renewable energy generation

WtE is the process whereby energy (typically heat and electricity) is generated using waste as a fuel source. This will usually be achieved through direct combustion of the waste using incinerators (i.e. burning the waste) or the production of a combustible fuel from a gas such as methane – this latter method is less common and requires processes such as gasification or anaerobic digestion. By reducing the need for landfills, WtE reduces emissions and land pollutants. It also provides sources of renewable energy (waste being ‘renewable’ as a source of energy that can be used for fuel without – feasibly – running out).

WtE is a relatively ‘old’ method of energy recovery, at least in so far as heat from waste incineration was used to power turbines (dating back as far as the 19th century, with “water wall” incinerators). Nowadays it is a popular source of renewable energy. For example, as of 28 May 2024, the US disposed of 12% of its municipal solid waste per year by burning it for energy. This figure rises significantly, to 75%, for Japan and Scandinavian countries. WtE is particularly attractive as an energy source and waste management technique for physically smaller countries by landmass, given that less land is used as landfill as a direct result.[1]

Whilst these projects offer a dual benefit of reducing landfill waste and generating energy, they are not without environmental concerns – particularly in relation to emissions. The incineration process can release pollutant gases if not properly managed. For this reason, modern WtE facilities are equipped with advanced pollution control technologies, including scrubbers, filters and electrostatic precipitators, to minimise these emissions and to comply with more stringent environmental standards. There is also increasing integration of carbon capture technology into WtE plants, which can result in zero, or even negative CO2 emissions.

These issues notwithstanding, as the Middle East witnesses a significant increase in waste generation due to rapid urbanisation, population growth, and industrial activities, WtE projects have emerged as a viable solution for waste management, turning waste into a resource while addressing environmental concerns.

Major Waste-to-Energy Projects in the Middle East

There are many ‘state of the art’ WtE facilities in the Middle East. The following list of a number of the region’s facilities gives some sense of scope and scale:

1. Dubai Waste Management Centre, UAE

The Dubai Waste Management Centre, set to be the world’s largest WtE plant, is a landmark project in the UAE. With an investment of over US$1 billion, this facility will process 1.9 million tonnes of waste annually, generating approximately 200 megawatts of electricity. Scheduled for completion in 2024, this project underscores Dubai’s commitment to sustainability and clean energy.[2]

2. Bee’ah’s Sharjah WtE Plant, UAE

The Sharjah WtE plant, developed by Bee’ah and Masdar, was the first of its kind in the UAE. This US$220 million project will process over 300,000 tonnes of waste annually, generating 30 megawatts of energy, sufficient to power 28,000 homes. The plant supports Sharjah’s goal of achieving zero waste to landfill.[3]

3. Amman WtE Project, Jordan

Jordan’s capital, Amman, is home to a major WtE project aimed at addressing the city’s waste management challenges. The facility will process around 1,800 tonnes of waste daily, producing 45 megawatts of electricity. This initiative is part of Jordan’s broader strategy to enhance renewable energy capacity and reduce environmental impact.[4]

4. Kuwait WtE Plant, Kuwait

Kuwait’s ambitious WtE project is designed to process 3,275 tonnes of municipal solid waste daily, generating 100 megawatts of power. This US$1.5 billion project aligns with Kuwait’s Vision 2035, aiming to improve waste management infrastructure and promote sustainable development.

Challenges in the Waste-to-Energy Sector

The WtE sector faces various challenges in the race to implement more cutting-edge technologies and thus is prone to disputes. This is for a number of reasons – the high capital investment, the technically complex nature of the projects and the technology deployed, the number of stakeholders involved (including government entities), intricate regulatory frameworks and significant environmental and financial implications. These can lead to disputes amongst the range of project participants (including investors, contractors and operators).

In particular, the design, construction and operation of a WtE project is technically complex and expensive. The result is an environment ripe for a range of contractual disputes – both during construction and when the plant is being operated and maintained. It is, therefore, imperative for all the relevant stakeholders to have the proper contractual arrangements in place with the appropriate protections. Managing the project effectively is also vitally important.

The types of challenges which may lead to disputes include the following:

1. Contractual Disputes

Contractual arrangements for WtE projects are particularly complex. Structures involving multiple stakeholders, such as government entities, private companies, and international partners, can lead to disagreements over terms, performance and responsibilities, both during construction and during operation. In the construction supply chain, package scoping is critical to address the risks posed by the interface of the various works packages.

In particular, acceptance tests, whereby the WtE facilities meet certain tests in terms of fuel output tied to payment terms, are notoriously difficult to draft and subsequently comply with. This is because the output of the plants is wholly dependent on the inputted waste – which is a direct result of government/local government policy (i.e. what is recycled? What waste is delivered to the plant? How often is the waste collected/delivered? How decomposed is it on delivery? How safe are the assumptions as to these issues at contract stage?).

The Middle East can implement learnings from experience garnered overseas, where various WtE projects have resulted in expensive litigation – in particular, in the United Kingdom. Such litigation has included the complete collapse of individual projects which, although constructed, could never meet the acceptance criteria, or the demise of sophisticated and experienced EPC contractors who were left facing design and construction responsibility on riskier projects.

2. Regulatory and Compliance Issues

Navigating the regulatory landscape is critical for the success of WtE projects. Disputes may arise from non-compliance with environmental regulations, permitting challenges, and changes in legislation. Rules and regulations change quickly in the waste sector, and this can lead to a range of disputes depending upon the impact of the changes.

3. Financing and Investment Disputes

Given the significant capital investment required for WtE projects, disputes over financing, funding delays, and returns on investment are common. Transparent financial planning and risk-sharing arrangements can address these issues.

4. Technological and Operational Challenges

Technological advancements in this sector are fast-paced. The integration of new technologies in WtE plants can lead to a variety of disputes, particularly regarding performance standards, maintenance, and technology transfer. Further, the integration between the waste products that the technology requires to produce the agreed output, and the waste products that are delivered to the plant, can be different, resulting in the plant’s under or non-performance as against contractual performance criteria – criteria that was often devised on assumptions as to the input waste to be provided and the yet to be proven capability of the new technology.

Disputes may also arise in relation to grid connection, as well as regarding the arrangements for off-taking electricity.

5. Community and Environmental Concerns

Public opposition and environmental concerns can lead to legal challenges and project delays. This is one of the key driving factors behind changing regulations and government policy, which can lead to parties inadvertently failing to comply with contractually agreed terms.

Conclusion

The increase of waste-to-energy projects in the Middle East represents a significant and welcome step towards sustainable waste management and renewable energy generation in the region. While these projects offer immense benefits, they also present potential disputes that require careful management. Through understanding the complexities of the sector, WtE sector participants will be able to anticipate and in some circumstances mitigate those disputes.

 


[1] Waste-To-Energy Technology Explained & Examples | Perch Energy.

[2] About DWMC – DWMC.

[3] Masdar | Sharjah Waste-to-Energy Project.

[4] Greater Amman Municipality (GAM) Waste-to-Energy Project – Feasibility Study (ebrd.com).

Posted by: Emma Nierinck

Return to News & Insights
Loading